Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-23 Thread Mikko Järvinen
Hello Well, setup.exe is also Windows only. You still have different install commands for Windows, MacOS and Linux. I cannot see any reason why msi package and CCK2 couldn't work together. It is just about authoring the msi and providing a clever way to define the customizations and settings.

Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-23 Thread Gustafsson Martin (SEIT)
I agree that the setup.exe is a much better way of deploying than a MSI-wrapped .exe but it is not industry standard to deploy in this way to large environments. Looking forward with modern deployment it will be MSI or APPX in the frontline to deploy applications on Windows 10, not .exe files.

Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-22 Thread Jason Jackson
Yes, let's not forget that MSI is Windows only. With CCK2, we can use the same config files on different OS. We deploy a lot of applications with SCCM, and in my opinion, the MSI-based ones aren't any better or easier. -- Jason Jackson Computer Systems

Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-22 Thread James M. Pulver
Personally, I like the current setup once I got Puppet going. The reason is consistent configuration for Windows, Linux and Mac. I wouldn't want to do 2 or more attempts to apply the same configuration across the platforms, at that point, I lose a lot of benefit from Firefox. James Pulver

Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-22 Thread Alexandre Gauvrit
+1 If finally Mozilla would release an official Firefox MSI package, it would be good to follow previous comments on the real goals of an MSI package. * deploy Firefox through GPO for medium to big structures * manage Firefox system preferences (default proxy, extensions, security

Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-22 Thread Luca Manganelli
Il 21/08/2017 15:53, Mikko Järvinen ha scritto: If Mozilla is going to provide msi packages of their products the whole process must be seamlessly integrated into the automated build process. Every single resource, like files and registry settings, must belong into a one and only one Windows

Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-21 Thread Mikko Järvinen
Hi Unfortunately there seems to be some misunderstanding from Mozilla's part about msi packages (and Windows Installer) and why many customers have for over ten years expressed their desire to get msi packages straight from Mozilla. Providing an msi wrapper as a solution quite misses the

Re: [Mozilla Enterprise] Request for feedback: a MSI installer of Firefox

2017-08-21 Thread Gustafsson Martin (SEIT)
Hi Ledru! I just did a quick check of the MSI and, with all due respect, custom action wrapping an .exe-file in to an MSI with a silent switch is not really something that makes anyones life easier from an enterprise perspective. The strengths of an MSI comes from the different database tables