November 19, 2013 Meeting Notes

2013-11-27 Thread Rick Waldron
# Nov 19 Meeting Notes John Neumann (JN), Allen Wirfs-Brock (AWB), Yehuda Katz (YK), Eric Ferraiuolo (EF), Erik Arvidsson (EA), Rick Hudson (RH), Matt Sweeney (MS), Rafael Weinstein (RWS), Alex Russell (AR), Rick Waldron (RW), Dmitry Soshnikov (DS), Jeff Morrison (JM), Sebastian Markbage (SM),

Re: November 19, 2013 Meeting Notes

2013-11-27 Thread David Bruant
Le 27/11/2013 19:14, Rick Waldron a écrit : # Nov 19 Meeting Notes ## 4.4 Finalizing the Proxy API for ES6 (Presented by Tom Van Cutsem) (...) DS: What is typeof and instanceof AWB/BE: object BE: Capital P AWB: Ca??? DS: Whatever Proxy creates? BE: That depends on what is created. DS:

Re: November 19, 2013 Meeting Notes

2013-11-27 Thread Tom Van Cutsem
2013/11/27 David Bruant bruan...@gmail.com Le 27/11/2013 19:14, Rick Waldron a écrit : BE: typeof depends if there is a call trap. instanceof depends on the prototype chain. All in the spec, so can create any object (apart from private state issues) Shouldn't it depend on the target's

Re: November 19, 2013 Meeting Notes

2013-11-27 Thread Brendan Eich
Thanks, Tom -- your whole bulleted list looks good, but in particular: Tom Van Cutsem wrote: (the current draft does lose the ability for a proxy to transparently retain a non-standard typeof value. AFAICT, typeof proxy will always either return object or function) This seems right. Any