Re: existence of stars

2001-06-02 Thread Saibal Mitra
You'll have to ask Bruno, because that's what he wrote. On 01-Jun-01, Saibal Mitra wrote: BTW, do you know that Godel wrote a formalisation in the modal logic system S5 of St. Anselm proof of the existence of God? (I'm not sure there is any evidence that Godel takes his proof seriously,

Re: existence of stars

2001-06-02 Thread Saibal Mitra
Bruno wrote: Saibal wrote: (complete message below for the FORers) Can't we prove that stars (and for that matter anything we observe) exist in at least some universes? But does some universes exists ? To tell you frankly I have a problem with the word universe. I guess you take it as

Re: existence of stars

2001-06-01 Thread Marchal
(following indeed St. Anselm) that if God exists and if stars exists, then God sees stars. Charles Goodwin comments: Who says there's no evidence for the existence of stars? I for one am a convinced stellist and firmly believe that stars exist. (Including the Sun - it's bigger than me so I don't

Re: existence of stars

2001-06-01 Thread Brent Meeker
On 01-Jun-01, Saibal Mitra wrote: BTW, do you know that Godel wrote a formalisation in the modal logic system S5 of St. Anselm proof of the existence of God? (I'm not sure there is any evidence that Godel takes his proof seriously, but it is a nice little piece of exact and very modest