RE: Reference class (was dualism and the DA)

2005-06-21 Thread Jonathan Colvin
Russell Standish wrote: > > I'd be interested to hear it. Here's something else you could look > > at...calculate the median annual income for all humans > alive today (I > > believe it is around $4,000 /year), compare it to your own, > and see if > > you are anyway near the median. I predict

Re: Reference class (was dualism and the DA)

2005-06-20 Thread Russell Standish
On Mon, Jun 20, 2005 at 12:52:23PM -0700, Jonathan Colvin wrote: > > That's quite an assumption. *Do* all conscious things ask this question of > themselves? Babies don't. Senile old people don't. I'm not sure that > medieval peasants ever thought to ask this question, or pre-literate > cavemen.

Re: Reference class (was dualism and the DA)

2005-06-20 Thread Russell Standish
Almost the right answer. In fact, if you download the population of countries from the US Census bureau, throw them into a histogram, you will find that the distribution is best fit with a power law, with exponent -1 (my best fit was actually -1.05, but it was -1 within error). This implies that th

Re: Reference class (was dualism and the DA)

2005-06-20 Thread Saibal Mitra
- Original Message - From: "Jonathan Colvin" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "'Russell Standish'" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: "'EverythingList'" Sent: Monday, June 20, 2005 09:52 PM Subject: Reference class (was dualism and the DA)

Reference class (was dualism and the DA)

2005-06-20 Thread Jonathan Colvin
Russell Standish wrote: > > > >(JC) If you want to insist that "What would it be like > to be a bat" > > > >is equivalent to the question "What would the universe be like > > > if I had > > > > been a bat rather than me?", it is very hard to see what the > > > > answer could be. Suppose you >