Brent Meeker writes:> You don't have to. Body identity is not sufficient to establish the "fact of the matter". People > may be acquited to murder (by reason of insanity) because they suffer from multiple personality > disorder. In such cases, one "personality" is generally not aware of the ot
Bruno Marchal writes:> > In any case, it is telling that even Parfit's philosophical > > adversaries do not focus on lack of scientific plausibility as an > > argument against *philosophical* validity. For the most part, he could > > have made the same points had he been writing a century ago, dr
Stathis Papaioannou wrote:
> Brent Meeker writes:
>
> >
> You don't have to. Body identity is not sufficient to establish the "fact of
> the matter". People
> >
> may be acquited to murder (by reason of insanity) because they suffer from
> multiple personality
> >
> disorder. In such
3 matches
Mail list logo
