Re: Speaking about Mathematicalism

2007-04-07 Thread 1Z
On 3 Apr, 20:08, Brent Meeker [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Bruno Marchal wrote: That brings up an issue which has troubled me. Why arithmetic? It's widely agreed on. Otherwise there would e problems about the existence of those platonic objects which can only be defined with certain,

Re: Speaking about Mathematicalism

2007-04-07 Thread John M
IZ wrote: ...arithmetic? It's widely agreed on In my oppinion scientific argumentation is not a democratic vote. Scientists overwhelmingly agreed in the Flat Earth. THEN: science changed and the general vote went for heliocentrism. THEN... IZ continued: ... Otherwise there would (b)e