The ASSA leads to a unique utilitarism

2007-10-01 Thread Youness Ayaita
In this message, I neither want to support the ASSA nor utilitarism. But I will argue that the former has remarkable consequences for the latter. To give a short overview of the concepts, I remind you that utilitarism is a doctrine measuring the morality of an action only by its outcome. Those

Re: against UD+ASSA, part 1

2007-10-01 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
On 01/10/2007, Jesse Mazer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is the DA incompatible with QI? According to MWI, your measure in the multiverse is constantly dropping with age as versions of you meet their demise. According to DA, your present OM is 95% likely to be in the first 95% of all OM's

Re: RSSA / ASSA / Single Mind Theory

2007-10-01 Thread Jason Resch
On 4/29/07, Jason [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Two things in my mind make personal identity fuzzy: 1. The MWI of quantum mechanics, which if true means each person experiences a perhaps infinite number of histories across the multi- verse. Should personal identity extend to just one branch or

Re: RSSA / ASSA / Single Mind Theory

2007-10-01 Thread Vladimir Nesov
Also single mind can be regarded as collection of parts interacting with each other. If each part can be regarded as its information content, each physical implementation ties together instantiations of parts. If single mind can be implemented by multiple implementations, each of these

Re: RSSA / ASSA / Single Mind Theory

2007-10-01 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
On 02/10/2007, Vladimir Nesov [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Also single mind can be regarded as collection of parts interacting with each other. If each part can be regarded as its information content, each physical implementation ties together instantiations of parts. If single mind can be

Re: against UD+ASSA, part 1

2007-10-01 Thread Jesse Mazer
Stathis Papaioannou wrote: On 01/10/2007, Jesse Mazer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I guess if you believe there is no real temporal relation between OMs, that any sense of an observer who is successively experiencing a series of different OMs is an illusion and that the only real

Re: RSSA / ASSA / Single Mind Theory

2007-10-01 Thread Vladimir Nesov
Not single mind is half-zombified, but single brain. Half of the brain implements half of the mind, and another half of the brain is zombie. Another half of the mind (corresponding to zombie part of the brain) exists as information content and can be implemented in different universe. This view

Re: RSSA / ASSA / Single Mind Theory

2007-10-01 Thread Jesse Mazer
Vladimir Nesov wrote: Not single mind is half-zombified, but single brain. Half of the brain implements half of the mind, and another half of the brain is zombie. Another half of the mind (corresponding to zombie part of the brain) exists as information content and can be implemented in

Re: RSSA / ASSA / Single Mind Theory

2007-10-01 Thread Vladimir Nesov
Are you asking why I consider notion of p-zombieness meaningful? On 10/2/07, Jesse Mazer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Vladimir Nesov wrote: Not single mind is half-zombified, but single brain. Half of the brain implements half of the mind, and another half of the brain is zombie. Another

Re: RSSA / ASSA / Single Mind Theory

2007-10-01 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
On 02/10/2007, Vladimir Nesov [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Not single mind is half-zombified, but single brain. Half of the brain implements half of the mind, and another half of the brain is zombie. Another half of the mind (corresponding to zombie part of the brain) exists as information