Re: The Prestige (Spoiler Alert) and First Person Indeterminacy

2015-05-05 Thread Dennis Ochei
Computer scientist's or. If you read it that way it's a yes or no question. Misreading an exclusive or as an inclusive or is often used in CS/Math jokes. He's also indicating that his model of personal identity allows branching, i.e. you're both. If you think you will be the Prestige

Re: The Prestige (Spoiler Alert) and First Person Indeterminacy

2015-05-05 Thread LizR
It's a question to which the answer could be yes, I would be the man in the box or the man in the prestige (believes only one is the original, and the other is a copy that doesn't preserve the original's consciousness) or yes, I will be the man in the box and the man in the prestige (believes

Re: The Prestige (Spoiler Alert) and First Person Indeterminacy

2015-05-04 Thread John Clark
On Mon, May 4, 2015 at 10:48 AM, Jason Resch jasonre...@gmail.com wrote: John Clark, you have often praised the movie The Prestige on this list. I am curious to know, how did you interpret the line: Would I be the man in the box or the prestige? I would answer yes. John K Clark -- You

Re: The Prestige (Spoiler Alert) and First Person Indeterminacy

2015-05-04 Thread Jason Resch
Yes to what? It wasn't a yes or no question. Jason On Mon, May 4, 2015 at 11:49 AM, John Clark johnkcl...@gmail.com wrote: On Mon, May 4, 2015 at 10:48 AM, Jason Resch jasonre...@gmail.com wrote: John Clark, you have often praised the movie The Prestige on this list. I am curious to

Re: The Prestige (Spoiler Alert) and First Person Indeterminacy

2015-05-04 Thread John Clark
On Mon, May 4, 2015 Jason Resch jasonre...@gmail.com wrote: Yes to what? It wasn't a yes or no question. Given the way the personal pronoun was used I think it was a yes or no question. John K Clark Jason On Mon, May 4, 2015 at 11:49 AM, John Clark johnkcl...@gmail.com wrote: On