Re: [ewg] Status of SDP? (and ib_sdp patch for Linux-3.4.x)

2012-04-23 Thread Doug Ledford
On 04/23/2012 01:25 PM, richard Croucher wrote: What's makes SDP so useful and why is will be sorely missed is that it does not require users to refactor existing TCP socket code, or even be in possession of the source code for that matter. Neither does IPoIB, and there are no legal questions

Re: [ewg] Status of SDP? (and ib_sdp patch for Linux-3.4.x)

2012-04-23 Thread Hefty, Sean
What's makes SDP so useful and why is will be sorely missed is that it does not require users to refactor existing TCP socket code, or even be in possession of the source code for that matter. Simply preloading libsdp is all need to do to convert that old, cranky tcp program to run (almost)

Re: [ewg] Status of SDP? (and ib_sdp patch for Linux-3.4.x)

2012-04-20 Thread richard Croucher
IMHO Mellanox would rather sell you their VMA than have you use a free SDP. I assume that they have stopped maintaining SDP. It's a great shame to see it dropped. It a good way for people to get going with InfiniBand, particularly since IPoIB performance is so poor. -- Richard Croucher

Re: [ewg] Status of SDP? (and ib_sdp patch for Linux-3.4.x)

2012-04-20 Thread Woodruff, Robert J
Ben wrote, Oh. Is there another ULP that replaces it? Offer the same feat.? Sean is working on an alternative socket-like API called rsockets that you might be interested in. It is completely user-space library and does not have any Microsoft IP issues. This may be an acceptable alternative to

Re: [ewg] Status of SDP? (and ib_sdp patch for Linux-3.4.x)

2012-04-14 Thread Tziporet Koren
So where did it go? Is SDP obsolete? its deprecated Also, without knowing above status, I ported ib_sdp.ko in OFED-1.5 to Linux 3.4.0-rc1 just so I can try it out (I'm also trying out ib_srpt, so I needed recent enough kernel). # For anyone interested, I pasted the diff to #

[ewg] Status of SDP? (and ib_sdp patch for Linux-3.4.x)

2012-04-10 Thread Taisuke Yamada
Hi. I recently starting trying out SDP, and also noticed it is gone from OFED. In recent exchange in this group, it was stated SDP is not part of OFED any more. So where did it go? Is SDP obsolete? Also, without knowing above status, I ported ib_sdp.ko in OFED-1.5 to Linux 3.4.0-rc1 just so I