[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-11-19 Thread Carl Eugen Hoyos
Carl Eugen Hoyos ceho...@rainbow.studorg.tuwien.ac.at added the comment: This looks ok afaict. -- status: open - closed substatus: needs_more_info - fixed FFmpeg issue tracker iss...@roundup.ffmpeg.org

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-22 Thread pinxue
pinxue pin...@gmail.com added the comment: I'm glad to have your observation. We removed configure because we didn't figured out how to make it work with NDK yet, so that we removed it to avoid confuse developers interested. Because we have done this kind of cleanup, some files are deleted by

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-22 Thread pinxue
pinxue pin...@gmail.com added the comment: Done, I add following note in INSTALL 1 RockPlayer notes: 2 Following is method used by original FFmpeg. Which doesn't work with 3 Android NDK yet. 4 5 Please use Android.mk to build the .so by standard Android NDK way. 6 Added doc and

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-21 Thread Doug Stevenson
Doug Stevenson dougn...@hyper-aware.com added the comment: It seems to me that if the instructions on FFmpeg's legal page are followed, then you are intentionally avoiding all issues with the LGPL license: http://www.ffmpeg.org/legal.html If you do this, you are making it easy for people to

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-20 Thread pinxue
pinxue pin...@gmail.com added the comment: Hi beafdefx or Doug Stevenson, creator of Act 1 Video Player for Android, I just found we have long email thread discussion in same day when this case is filed, so that I guess you already have the link to download this source code package at that

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-19 Thread Doug Stevenson
Doug Stevenson dougn...@hyper-aware.com added the comment: The provided source seems to be missing useful and accurate instructions on how it was created/modified, how to use it, or how to introduce new versions of FFmpeg back into the application for all of the three target platforms for which

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-19 Thread pinxue
pinxue pin...@gmail.com added the comment: As this project is building a native library for Android platform, I believe it is safe to assume the user understands how to use Android NDK, Google provides full document online as well. Android.mk contains following lines: #LOCAL_SRC_FILES

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-17 Thread pinxue
pinxue pin...@gmail.com added the comment: Firstly, RockPlayer uses ffmpeg.so to decode video, but deosn't use its function for video rendering. Secondary, any user of RockPlayer knows the official website is http://www.anplayer.com or http://rockplayer.freecoder.org (two are same).

[issue2101] RockPlayer Android app in violation of license agreement

2010-07-17 Thread Benjamin Larsson
Benjamin Larsson ba...@ludd.ltu.se added the comment: On 17/07/10 21:58, pinxue wrote: pinxue pin...@gmail.com added the comment: Firstly, RockPlayer uses ffmpeg.so to decode video, but deosn't use its function for video rendering. Secondary, any user of RockPlayer knows the official