Johannes Gebauer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Certainly no modern vibrato, but no vibrato would be just as
wrong...
In fact I am absolutely more vibrato was done in Bach's time than
between 1750 and 1850. A controversal view, I know.
I would be interested to hear your reasons and evidence,
On 09.09.2007 Ken Moore wrote:
I would be interested to hear your reasons and evidence, especially for a
reduction in its use c. 1750. Spohr (c. 1840) I know, and Joachim (c.1909) I
been told, describe vibrato as an embellishment to be used on particular notes,
possibly more by soloists than
On 9 Sep 2007 at 23:30, Johannes Gebauer wrote:
it seems to
me that 19th century treatises are much more particular about the use of
vibrato.
I'm very intrigued by your idea, and don't mean this comment as in
any way an effort to refute your hypothesis, but the fact is that the
19th
