[Fis] Fw: Information Conservation in black holes

2016-01-30 Thread Joseph Brenner
Dear John, Sorry you have been ill. I agree fully with your statement: All of these explanations, and even stating the problem, require information notions, not just energy as in classical physics. What I object to are statements or implications that information, whether in boundaries or

[Fis] Information Conservation in black holes

2016-01-30 Thread John Collier
List, Sorry I haven't been able to respond to the interesting remarks on my last post, but it took a while to digest them, and my current health concerns take up a lot of my time, so I haven't had time to come up with responses that are properly thought out. In the meantime, here is an