Re: [Fis] Fwd: _ Re: _ Gödel discussion

2016-05-06 Thread Francesco Rizzo
Cari Tutti, Alex, Lou, mi permetto di far notare che bisogna distinguere o non confondere: macchine, meccanismi e meccanicamente. Dire che non siamo macchine è una cosa ovvia, ma sostenere che gli uomini non devono ragionare meccanicamente non è per niente ovvio. Non Vi pare? Grazie. Francesco

[Fis] Fwd: _ Re: _ Gödel discussion

2016-05-05 Thread Alex Hankey
By the way, the argument below was sent to me by Lou Kauffman. On 4 May 2016 at 20:11, Alex Hankey wrote: > Dear Fis Colleagues, > > I received this comment on Lucas's argument that seems to me short and > sweet, > so I am posting it for our general edification. > > Best

[Fis] Fwd: _ Re: _ Gödel discussion

2016-05-04 Thread Alex Hankey
Dear Fis Colleagues, I received this comment on Lucas's argument that seems to me short and sweet, so I am posting it for our general edification. Best wishes, Alex -- Forwarded message -- “Proving” that we are not machines is somewhat quixotic from my point of view, in that