Re: [Flac-dev] Flac and lyrics

2009-08-31 Thread Brian Willoughby
FLAC supports Application-specific metadata blocks. Although I am not aware of any which are specific to lyrics, you could create your own. If nothing exists, and you were to make a proposal for review by the community, then I'm sure you could start a new standard. On that topic, what

Re: [Flac-dev] Flac and lyrics

2009-08-31 Thread Scot Thompson
FLAC already handles Vorbis comments, why not just put the lyrics into a comment? All the existing players are likely to look there anyway. I know that's what I did when I wrote the plugins for MediaCenter. -Original Message- From: flac-dev-boun...@xiph.org

Re: [Flac-dev] Flac and lyrics

2009-08-31 Thread Ben Allison
Both MPEG-4 File Format (mp4) and Matroska (mkv) have an interesting format for lyrics and subtitles. Since these container formats can contain multiple contain streams, lyrics or subtitles are just another stream interleaved with the rest of the data. They are synchronized by having timestamps

Re: [Flac-dev] Flac and lyrics

2009-08-31 Thread Conrad Parker
2009/9/1 Ben Allison ben...@winamp.com: Both MPEG-4 File Format (mp4) and Matroska (mkv) have an interesting format for lyrics and subtitles.  Since these container formats can contain multiple contain streams, lyrics or subtitles are just another stream interleaved with the rest of the data.  

Re: [Flac-dev] Flac and lyrics

2009-08-31 Thread Didier Dambrin
there are already 2 ways to stuff lyrics in MP3's, a basic text one and a complex time-stamped one, that's your best chance if you want players (or rather plugins in popular players) to ever read them http://www.id3.org/Lyrics3v2 - Original Message - From: Ben Allison