Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-28 Thread Vincent Hennebert
This vote was launched while discussion was still going on on the mailing list. It would have been good to wait that a consensus is reached, which I don’t think has happened yet. What was the urgency to launch the vote now? I haven’t received any answer to my concerns about the following metrics:

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-28 Thread Peter Hancock
I will vote -0 with reasons I have already expressed in the 'Merge Request - Temp_ComplexScripts into Trunk' thread. I hope we can go forward refining this work, along with the rest FOP, through constructive collaboration, respecting the varied degrees of experiences, expertises and passion that

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-28 Thread Simon Pepping
Seven committers voted. There were five +1 votes and no -1 votes. There was one -0.9 vote and one -0 vote. According to the Project Charter three +1 ('yes' votes) with no -1 ('no' votes or vetoes) are needed to approve a significant code change. Therefore the proposal to merge the

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-28 Thread Glenn Adams
Thank you FOP team. As I have stated previously, I am prepared to improve and maintain this code moving forward, including adding comments for local variables not already described, and refactoring certain classes to reduce class size. I've also given some thought to moving the new CS classes in

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread Pascal Sancho
I vote positive too: +1 Le 25/10/2011 10:31, Simon Pepping a écrit : With his latest patch, Glenn Adams wrote: With this latest patch I am satisfied that there is sufficient testing and stability in the CS branch to support its merger into trunk. Therefore, I request that such a merge be

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread Chris Bowditch
On 25/10/2011 09:31, Simon Pepping wrote: With his latest patch, Glenn Adams wrote: Hi All, With this latest patch I am satisfied that there is sufficient testing and stability in the CS branch to support its merger into trunk. Therefore, I request that such a merge be accomplished after

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread The Web Maestro
Following this request, I herewith propose to merge the branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk, and launch a formal vote. I vote positive: +1 For the rules of voting about code commits, see the project charter, article 11, http://wiki.apache.org/xmlgraphics/ProjectCharter. Simon Pepping

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread Pascal Sancho
Hi, There was a discussion about enabling it by default, with some performances tests. see http://marc.info/?l=fop-devm=131108266423848w=2 Le 25/10/2011 14:54, The Web Maestro a écrit : Following this request, I herewith propose to merge the branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk, and launch a

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread Clay Leeds
Thanks Pascal! And thank you Glenn! Great work! +1 from me! My religion is simple. My religion is kindness. - HH The Dalai Lama of Tibet On Oct 25, 2011, at 6:29 AM, Pascal Sancho pascal.san...@takoma.fr wrote: Hi, There was a discussion about enabling it by default, with some

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread Glenn Adams
The short answer is that if you do not wish to be affected by complex script support, you can use the new -nocs command line option or you can specify complex-scripts disabled='true'/ in your FOP configuration file. Keep in mind that Latin (Roman), Cyrillic, and Greek scripts also benefit from

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread Simon Pepping
The vote runs for three days, and will end on Friday 28 October 2011 at 18:00h UTC. Simon Pepping On Tue, Oct 25, 2011 at 10:31:43AM +0200, Simon Pepping wrote: Following this request, I herewith propose to merge the branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk, and launch a formal vote. For the

Re: [VOTE] Merge branch Temp_ComplexScripts into trunk

2011-10-25 Thread Adrian Cumiskey
+1 from me. A lot of work, a great achievement. On 25 October 2011 12:10, Simon Pepping spepp...@leverkruid.eu wrote: The vote runs for three days, and will end on Friday 28 October 2011 at 18:00h UTC. Simon Pepping On Tue, Oct 25, 2011 at 10:31:43AM +0200, Simon Pepping wrote: