Re: [foreman-dev] [RFC] Deprecate and move Github RFC repo content

2017-11-29 Thread Lukas Zapletal
Yeah I think I misinterpreted how this feature works. I thought its just a discussion per project. This is per team I guess, as you pointed out. Ok I am migrating back to wiki unless there is some blocker raised. LZ On Wed, Nov 29, 2017 at 11:37 AM, Greg Sutcliffe

Re: [foreman-dev] [RFC] Deprecate and move Github RFC repo content

2017-11-29 Thread Greg Sutcliffe
On 29/11/17 08:47, Daniel Lobato Garcia wrote: > If it helps, I think > https://github.com/blog/2471-introducing-team-discussions looks also > like a good tool for these kind of discussions, without any need for > a moderator. The discussions are restricted to people in the GitHub > team. TLDR:

Re: Re: [foreman-dev] [RFC] Deprecate and move Github RFC repo content

2017-11-29 Thread Lukas Zapletal
Yeah, I also think this would make sense. It's basically a wiki with discussion - ideal. Greg, can you turn it on in RFC repo so we can test this? If this fails, we can move to wiki and deprecate that repo. -- LZ Lukas @lzap Zapletal -- You received this message because you are subscribed

Re: Re: [foreman-dev] [RFC] Deprecate and move Github RFC repo content

2017-11-29 Thread Daniel Lobato Garcia
On 11/15, Tomer Brisker wrote: > Since I already suggested this some months ago, obvious +1 from me :) > > On Wed, Nov 15, 2017 at 1:41 PM, Greg Sutcliffe > wrote: > > +1 to moving them to the Redmine wiki. The RFC repo was a good > > experiment but handled badly (at

Re: [foreman-dev] [RFC] Deprecate and move Github RFC repo content

2017-11-15 Thread Greg Sutcliffe
+1 to moving them to the Redmine wiki. The RFC repo was a good experiment but handled badly (at least some of the blame for that is on me). At this point I don't think it's possible to rescue it. On 15/11/17 10:52, Sean O'Keeffe wrote: > Without wanting to hijack this thread... I think this is

Re: [foreman-dev] [RFC] Deprecate and move Github RFC repo content

2017-11-15 Thread Sean O'Keeffe
Yea +1 from me too. I think the biggest problem was that merging them has no direct link to the issue or PRs that resolved a RFC, this meant the author or someone had to remember to go back, ping someone to merge which often didn't happen. Whereas with a mailing list its okay to leave a thread

[foreman-dev] [RFC] Deprecate and move Github RFC repo content

2017-11-15 Thread Lukas Zapletal
Hey, this is another proposal to deprecate Github RFC repo and move the content to our wiki. Reasons: A) There is zero merged proposals for the past year (Jan-Nov 2017): https://github.com/theforeman/rfcs/commits/master B) Activity is very low (comments in 3 PRs last winter, 3 PRs last summer,