Re: [fossil-dev] andygoth-branch-list

2016-11-19 Thread Richard Hipp
On 11/19/16, Andy Goth wrote: > One final thing. Richard, I don't have commit access to SQLite since I > never requested it, but I did sign its contributor agreement at the same > time as I signed Fossil's agreement. Would you welcome my attempt to > incorporate your words about the special behavi

Re: [fossil-dev] andygoth-branch-list

2016-11-19 Thread Andy Goth
Jan, I'm not sure you and Richard concur, or maybe you and I don't concur on the meaning of the word "concur." ;^) "A closed branch should be a branch in which all leaves are closed" is not the definition Richard advocated. If I understand him correctly, he said to use the "/brlist definition" whi

Re: [fossil-dev] andygoth-branch-list

2016-11-19 Thread Jan Nijtmans
Op 19 nov. 2016 6:25 p.m. schreef "Richard Hipp": > On 11/19/16, Andy Goth wrote: > > Going forward, which definition do we want? > > I think the definition used by /brlist. > > Reasoning: > (1) I don't think the difference is all that important. If you have > multiple branches with the same name,

Re: [fossil-dev] andygoth-branch-list

2016-11-19 Thread Richard Hipp
On 11/19/16, Andy Goth wrote: > Is this extension documented? What is the precise behavior? Are there > guarantees that it will be preserved throughout future versions of SQLite? > When was it introduced? I thought I had documented this someplace, but now I cannot find where. In any event, it is

Re: [fossil-dev] andygoth-branch-list

2016-11-19 Thread Andy Goth
Is this extension documented? What is the precise behavior? Are there guarantees that it will be preserved throughout future versions of SQLite? When was it introduced? Repeating myself so we don't lose focus: I was originally looking at the inconsistent definition of open/closed branches. Given w

Re: [fossil-dev] andygoth-branch-list

2016-11-19 Thread Richard Hipp
On 11/19/16, Andy Goth wrote: > > If I understand correctly, the baseline branch ls query defines a closed > branch as having no leaves not referenced by closed tags. The baseline > "new" /brlist query instead checks whether "the" check-in is referenced > by a closed tag. Which check-in? Hard t