Re: [Foundation-l] [Langcom-l] Ancient Greek reconstructed an analysis of a proposal for a new Wikipedia

2011-09-21 Thread Gerard Meijssen
Hoi, The language policy does not allow for Wikipedia in extinct languages. However, a Wikisource for the old Greek languages does make sense. When such a Wikisource would be created, the user interface would by default not be in modern Greek because more people study old Greek outside Greece

Re: [Foundation-l] [Langcom-l] Ancient Greek reconstructed an analysis of a proposal for a new Wikipedia

2011-09-21 Thread John Vandenberg
2011/9/21 とある白い猫 to.aru.shiroi.n...@gmail.com: Yes but isn't multilingual wikisource more of an incubator rather than exclusively for historic texts? It would make more sense to separate the two as inherently the two tasks have different goals in mind. Multilingual Wikisource is a place for

Re: [Foundation-l] [Langcom-l] Ancient Greek reconstructed an analysis of a proposal for a new Wikipedia

2011-09-20 Thread とある白い猫
I think we may want a historic texts wikisource/wikibooks particularly for texts in now extinct languages. Something sort of like commons for historic texts for all extinct languages. I do not know something like this was proposed before. -- とある白い猫 (To Aru Shiroi Neko) On Fri, Apr 18, 2008

Re: [Foundation-l] [Langcom-l] Ancient Greek reconstructed an analysis of a proposal for a new Wikipedia

2011-09-20 Thread M. Williamson
Holy ancient thread revival, Batman! This seems like a good idea... but in the case of Wikisource, wouldn't that already be covered by multilingual Wikisource? 2011/9/20 とある白い猫 to.aru.shiroi.n...@gmail.com I think we may want a historic texts wikisource/wikibooks particularly for texts in

Re: [Foundation-l] [Langcom-l] Ancient Greek reconstructed an analysis of a proposal for a new Wikipedia

2011-09-20 Thread John Vandenberg
2011/9/21 M. Williamson node...@gmail.com: Holy ancient thread revival, Batman! This seems like a good idea... but in the case of Wikisource, wouldn't that already be covered by multilingual Wikisource? Yes, extinct/historical languages are collected by the multilingual Wikisource project.

Re: [Foundation-l] [Langcom-l] Ancient Greek reconstructed an analysis of a proposal for a new Wikipedia

2011-09-20 Thread とある白い猫
Yes but isn't multilingual wikisource more of an incubator rather than exclusively for historic texts? It would make more sense to separate the two as inherently the two tasks have different goals in mind. -- とある白い猫 (To Aru Shiroi Neko) 2011/9/20 John Vandenberg jay...@gmail.com 2011/9/21