Re: Locking and Mail spool Files

2001-03-26 Thread Ron 'The InSaNe One' Rosson
David Scheidt ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: On Sun, 25 Mar 2001, Marc W wrote: : :Excellent, I will look for that. However, in the meantime, on :older systems (3.x, 4.x, etc ...), is the below assertion correct? : You don't want to put mail spools on NFS filesystems. If you must, use

Locking and Mail spool Files

2001-03-25 Thread Marc W
So, in a discussion a while back, it was established that file locking is basically broken under NFS. Does this mean that it is simply a REALLY BAD idea to put mail spool files on NFS mounts, or are there ways that programs like /bin/mail can correctly ensure consistency while reading in

Re: Locking and Mail spool Files

2001-03-25 Thread Gordon Tetlow
Look for Alfred's commit of Mar 19th. There has been a *huge* overhaul of the nfs stuff and (I think) a working lockd. I haven't looked at it myself, so check it out for yourself. -gordon On Sun, 25 Mar 2001, Marc W wrote: So, in a discussion a while back, it was established that file

Re: Locking and Mail spool Files

2001-03-25 Thread Marc W
. - From: Gordon Tetlow [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Marc W [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: FreeBSD Hackers [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Locking and Mail spool Files Sent: 03/25/01 19:19 Look for Alfred's commit of Mar 19th. There has been a *huge* overhaul of the nfs stuff and (I

Re: Locking and Mail spool Files

2001-03-25 Thread Warner Losh
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED] Marc W writes: : Excellent, I will look for that. However, in the meantime, on : older systems (3.x, 4.x, etc ...), is the below assertion correct? I ran mail over NFS for a while, as well as using a mail program that didn't do locking to sort my mail. In both

Re: Locking and Mail spool Files

2001-03-25 Thread David Scheidt
On Sun, 25 Mar 2001, Marc W wrote: : :Excellent, I will look for that. However, in the meantime, on :older systems (3.x, 4.x, etc ...), is the below assertion correct? : You don't want to put mail spools on NFS filesystems. If you must, use the maildir format, ala qmail. David Scheidt

Re: Locking and Mail spool Files

2001-03-25 Thread Dan Nelson
In the last episode (Mar 25), Marc W said: So, in a discussion a while back, it was established that file locking is basically broken under NFS. Does this mean that it is simply a REALLY BAD idea to put mail spool files on NFS mounts, or are there ways that programs like /bin/mail can