Re: Nagios + 6.3-RELEASE == Hung Process
On 03/01/2008, at 11:56 AM, Marc G. Fournier wrote: As noted in my original report, this isn't a nagios issue per se ... my first experience with this issue was with Azureus/java ... so its a 'threading issue in general' ... A patch to force the package to link against libthr() has been committed [1] and should be available once mirrors update as net-mgmt/ nagios 2.10_1. This has been tested since this conversation stated in the net-mgmt/nagios-devel port [2] without any negative feedback being received. Bundled in the update is the inclusion of libltdl as requested by Tom Judge. I'd be interested to know how people go with the updated port. Thanks for your patience. [1] http://www.freebsd.org/cgi/query-pr.cgi?pr=120150 [2] http://www.freebsd.org/cgi/query-pr.cgi?pr=119246 Jarrod. ___ freebsd-questions@freebsd.org mailing list http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-questions To unsubscribe, send any mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Nagios + 6.3-RELEASE == Hung Process
On 03/01/2008, at 1:56 AM, Tom Judge wrote: I have also seen this issue, but have always put it down to the way that we manage our nagios deployments with cfengine. I will try to deploy this change and monitor for the problem to see if it persists. I hope I can confirm your frustrations. There is a threading issue with Nagios when it's binaries are linked against libpthread(3) threading library, the default on recent FreeBSD 5.x releases and all 6.x releases. The issue is random and extremely difficult to track down with the symptoms being a second Nagios process sitting on the system hanging a CPU. Be rest assured that I have been working on it, and have seen it on one system of mine. Changes have been submitted for net-mgmt/nagios-devel (aka Nagios 3.0.r1)) to force the build process to link against libthr(3) where available, removing the need to map libpthread() out with /etc/ libmap.conf. If this goes well, as stated in the PR, i'll back-port it to net-mgmt/nagios (aka Nagios 2.10) in the next few days. If anyone out there is running net-mgmt/nagios-devel and feels like trying it for me, see ports/119246 and drop me an email with a before and after ldd /usr/local/bin/nagios. On a side note if you want to use broker modules with nagios from port you need to change the following in the port Makefile in order to make them load properly: From: USE_AUTOTOOLS= autoconf:259 To: SE_AUTOTOOLS= autoconf:259 libltdl:15 I sent an email to the maintainer but got no response and my email did not seem to have affected the last commit to upgrade to 2.10 I did receive that email and the changes went in with the last commit of net-mgmt/nagios-devel to test. No issues have arisen so i'll be back-porting it to net-mgmt/nagios soon for you. There also has been a rather large ports freeze which delayed the upgrade to Nagios 2.10, that PR was submitted on the 1st of November and committed on the 13th of December. Unfortunately your email fell somewhere in the middle, apologies for not letting you know. Jarrod. ___ freebsd-questions@freebsd.org mailing list http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-questions To unsubscribe, send any mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Nagios + 6.3-RELEASE == Hung Process
On Wed, 2 Jan 2008, Tom Judge wrote: Jarrod Sayers wrote: I hope I can confirm your frustrations. There is a threading issue with Nagios when it's binaries are linked against libpthread(3) threading library, the default on recent FreeBSD 5.x releases and all 6.x releases. The issue is random and extremely difficult to track down with the symptoms being a second Nagios process sitting on the system hanging a CPU. Be rest assured that I have been working on it, and have seen it on one system of mine. Not sure if this is related at all but out of the 3 nagios deployments we have here I have only ever seen it on one (It currently has 2 nagios threads spinning CPU time atm). The differences on that server are: * It is amd64 compared to i386 * It also runs ndo2db from ndoutils 1.4b7 All the systems run 6.2-RELEASE-p5 and nagios-2.9_1, they are also all patched with gnu libltdl patch below. Don't know if that info is of any use to you. That's actually good to know, as you're now (unless I am mistaken) the first user to contact me about this problem on non-i386 systems. One user, plus myself, have also seen the issue under Nagios 3.x, both on i386 systems though. I also have a net-mgmt/ndoutils port in the works (less the database support for now) which also has the same issue so using broker modules doesn't seem to affect the outcome. My gut feeling is that it's not an architecture issue but more an interoperability issue between the Nagios threading code and the libpthread() threading library. [yoink] I did receive that email and the changes went in with the last commit of net-mgmt/nagios-devel to test. No issues have arisen so i'll be back-porting it to net-mgmt/nagios soon for you. There also has been a rather large ports freeze which delayed the upgrade to Nagios 2.10, that PR was submitted on the 1st of November and committed on the 13th of December. Unfortunately your email fell somewhere in the middle, apologies for not letting you know. Thanks for this, I currently maintain the patch on our build servers. No worries, I will look at bundling in the change with the libthr() fix over the next few days. Thanks for pointing that out too as it was a bug instead of a feature request, as on systems where the library was available, the build process would link to it. Hmm... Jarrod. ___ freebsd-questions@freebsd.org mailing list http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-questions To unsubscribe, send any mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]