Re: Attaching GELI device on boot

2013-03-24 Thread Fabian Keil
Stephan Schindel s...@tp1.rub.de wrote: i've got a problem attaching a geli device on boot. My setup: ada0 and ada1 full geli setup (no partition schemes). ZFS on both. ada0 is my root device. I can boot into the system there is no problem with it. But now I want to attach ada1 on boot as

Re: Attaching GELI device on boot

2013-03-24 Thread Stephan Schindel
Thank you for your answer. Are you sure that It is the geli rc script and not the kernel itself which could happen if the BOOT flag was set on ada1. I tried (un)setting the BOOT flag. With boot flag no key files are defined in loader.conf, which is fine: ada1 at ata5 bus 0 scbus5 target 0

Re: Attaching GELI device on boot

2013-03-24 Thread Stephan Schindel
This is the output at boot time: Configuring Disk Encryption for ada1. geli: Cannot read metadata from ada1: Inappropriate file type or format. Attach failed; attempt 1 of 3. ... And the Configuring... part is from /etc/rc.d/geli. One the system is ready the same attempt works fine:

Re: Attaching GELI device on boot

2013-03-24 Thread Stephan Schindel
OK I found the issue: I reinitialized the provider, same problem. Then I put a partition scheme (BSD) on it here it works fine. My guess is this is not intended and might be a bug. Geli should work fine for the whole disk (no scheme at all). It works fine for the root device, but fails when