Re: FreeBSD on GigaByte GA-8EGXDR-E?

2003-09-23 Thread Tom Munro Glass
Hi Dan,

Thanks for the very informative reply. I have searched the 4.8 & 5.1 
HARDWARE.TXT files and can find some but not all of the devices on this mobo. 
So I think you have convinced me not to buy that particular board!

The other option that I have been considering is to buy a Dell PowerEdge 
1600SC. I would be using the onboard SCSI Ultra 320 rather than RAID. I've 
searched the mailing lists and newsgroups for information about this, and I 
get the impression that the 1600SC is *probably* alright with FreeBSD 4.8, 
but I'd really appreciate confirmation of this.

Regards,

Tom


> > http://tw.giga-byte.com/Server/Products/Products_ServerBoard_GA-8EGXDR-E.
> >htm
> >
> > As far as I know, it's a current model.
>
> I found it.  For some reason it is categorized on the Gigabyte web site as
> a networking product rather than as a motherboard.
>
> I don't have any direct experience relevant to the compatibility of this
> motherboard with FreeBSD because my new Gigabyte motherboard, the 8KNXP,
> uses a different support chipset, the Intel 875P/ICH5R, and has a very
> different set of motherboard devices.
>
> I found that while FreeBSD runs reasonably well on my motherboard, FreeBSD
> does not support a large number of the more exotic motherboard devices.
> The situation is expected to improve a little bit when FreeBSD-5.2 comes
> out, whenever that happens.  Not soon I gather.  I frequently browse the
> freebsd-current mailing list.  FreeBSD-current looks sufficiently unstable
> that I don't want to mess with it.  FreeBSD-5.1 is flaky enough.
>
> Your motherboard seems to have an even more exotic set of motherboard
> devices and features.  I would check the HARDWARE.TXT file for the FreeBSD
> release you intend to run.  Devices not mentioned in the HARDWARE.TXT file
> are moderately likely to prove problematic.
>
> I see that your motherboard has an AWARD BIOS.  The AWARD BIOS on my
> motherboard does something strange that confuses the standard FreeBSD
> master bootstrap program (booteasy) as to which disk is really being
> booted so that I have to type F5 at it three times in order to boot.
>
> If the Intel ICH5R serial ATA controller on my motherboard is configured
> to operate in "native" mode, the AWARD BIOS fails to enter my serial ATA
> disks into the BIOS disk list.  Since I have to boot off my serial ATA
> disks, I have to configure them in "legacy" mode.  That means I can't use
> one of my standard ATA ports and that means I can't use standard ATA disks
> on my system (unless I buy an extra PCI ATA controller card for them).
>
> You may get lucky, but I expect you to have some exiting experiences
> in your future.
>
> Dan Strick
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> P.S. I find that Gigabyte email tech support is extremely sluggish
> and not very helpful.  If you have clout, please light a fire
> underneath those guys.

___
[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-questions
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[EMAIL PROTECTED]"


Re: FreeBSD on GigaByte GA-8EGXDR-E?

2003-09-23 Thread Dan Strick
> From: Tom Munro Glass <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> To: Dan Strick <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Subject: Re: FreeBSD on GigaByte GA-8EGXDR-E?
> Date: Wed, 24 Sep 2003 11:36:10 +1200
>
> Hi Dan,
>
> Try:  
>
> http://tw.giga-byte.com/Server/Products/Products_ServerBoard_GA-8EGXDR-E.htm
>
> As far as I know, it's a current model.

I found it.  For some reason it is categorized on the Gigabyte web site as
a networking product rather than as a motherboard.

I don't have any direct experience relevant to the compatibility of this
motherboard with FreeBSD because my new Gigabyte motherboard, the 8KNXP,
uses a different support chipset, the Intel 875P/ICH5R, and has a very
different set of motherboard devices.

I found that while FreeBSD runs reasonably well on my motherboard, FreeBSD
does not support a large number of the more exotic motherboard devices.
The situation is expected to improve a little bit when FreeBSD-5.2 comes
out, whenever that happens.  Not soon I gather.  I frequently browse the
freebsd-current mailing list.  FreeBSD-current looks sufficiently unstable
that I don't want to mess with it.  FreeBSD-5.1 is flaky enough.

Your motherboard seems to have an even more exotic set of motherboard
devices and features.  I would check the HARDWARE.TXT file for the FreeBSD
release you intend to run.  Devices not mentioned in the HARDWARE.TXT file
are moderately likely to prove problematic.

I see that your motherboard has an AWARD BIOS.  The AWARD BIOS on my
motherboard does something strange that confuses the standard FreeBSD
master bootstrap program (booteasy) as to which disk is really being
booted so that I have to type F5 at it three times in order to boot.

If the Intel ICH5R serial ATA controller on my motherboard is configured
to operate in "native" mode, the AWARD BIOS fails to enter my serial ATA
disks into the BIOS disk list.  Since I have to boot off my serial ATA
disks, I have to configure them in "legacy" mode.  That means I can't use
one of my standard ATA ports and that means I can't use standard ATA disks
on my system (unless I buy an extra PCI ATA controller card for them).

You may get lucky, but I expect you to have some exiting experiences
in your future.

Dan Strick
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

P.S. I find that Gigabyte email tech support is extremely sluggish
and not very helpful.  If you have clout, please light a fire
underneath those guys.
___
[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-questions
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[EMAIL PROTECTED]"