[Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bertho Grandpied
On Sat, 14 Jan 2012 Michael B. Brutman wrote : As far as 4K blocks go, I wouldn't worry about it too much.  512 byte  sectors will be supported either natively or by emulation in the drive  itself for a long time to come - at least 5 to 10 years.  Too many  existing systems depend on a 512

Re: [Freedos-user] FreeDOS 1.1 released

2012-01-15 Thread Bernd Blaauw
Op 15-1-2012 3:56, dos386 schreef: [Freedos-kernel] FreeDOS 1.1 released COOL :-) thanks, worked hard for it :) http://jafile.com/uploads/dos386/freeds11.png I like your style of coming up with screenshots, it clarifies issues quite nicely. I wish VMware's video feature would use standard

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bertho Grandpied
Eric Auer e.a...@jpberlin.de wrote : Interestingly, even 3 TB disks are still sold with 512 byte sectors. Conversely, even 1 TB USB disks are already sold with 2048 byte sectors ;=) (...snipping much...) By the way - a DRIVER could interface with any disk with any sector size and then just

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bernd Blaauw
Op 14-1-2012 23:23, Eric Auer schreef: Talking about new ways of booting, it would be very interesting to have a CD / DVD / BD boot loader for DOS. However, after you loaded the kernel, you still need some initrd from which you can load a CD/... driver pair like UIDE + SHSUCDX or ...CDROM +

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Michael B. Brutman
Bertho, I spoke from the point of view of the device (the hard drive) - if the hardware that the device is attached to chooses not to expose all of the options that the device supports, there is little the device can do about that. In the case of your external storage somebody made a design

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bret Johnson
FWIW: In my USB disk driver (USBDRIVE), here's what I've done. USBDRIVE does not try to virtualize the sector sizes as others are suggesting here as a possibility -- I figure doing that has the potential to cause as many problems as the alternative (using defective utilities/programs that are

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Eric Auer
Hi Bret, USBDRIVE does not try to virtualize the sector sizes as others are suggesting here as a possibility -- I figure doing that has the potential to cause as many problems as the alternative... Maybe you could make that configurable, so people can experiment with virtual 512 byte sectors

[Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bertho Grandpied
In reply to : Michael B. Brutman mbbrut...@brutman.com Michael, So the bottom line is that DOS will probably work just fine when natively attached to storage devices, and that will work for a long time.  Appliance storage devices are going to break that if they can't emulate 512 byte

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bertho Grandpied
In response to : Bret Johnson Subj : MSDOS - increasing max sector size ... Likewise, it will ignore disks with sector sizes larger than what DOS says it can handle (this particular detail is part of the easily accessible DOS List of Lists).  In the source code for USBDRIVE (starting at line

[Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bertho Grandpied
New follow-up ! In response to : Bret Johnson Subj : MSDOS - increasing max sector size quoting myself (sorry!) : According to Rudolf Loew, increasing maximum sector size in LoL of an unpatched MSDOS will work up to 2048 byte sectors, not 4096 :( I have not verified it for a fact. Wow!

Re: [Freedos-user] FreeDOS 1.1 released

2012-01-15 Thread teo gum
2012/1/15 dos386 dos...@gmail.com would be nice to know how many people actually installed it successfully on a __REAL__ PC ;-) I did and did it successfully. Yes, it did hang on the commandx but not mortally - for a while like some 2 minutes and then continued without problems. On a

Re: [Freedos-user] FreeDOS 1.1 released

2012-01-15 Thread teo gum
2012/1/15 dos386 dos...@gmail.com Other: - CWSDPMI, VSM, DOSNTLFN, ... are in - INFOPAD, 7-ZIP, UNTGZ, HX/HDPMI32, MPXPLAY, FASM, CC386, FREEBASIC, ARACHNE, ... are NOT in ... what can you do with it when installed ? As for the mpxplay copied it into /fdos/bin from the previous

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bret Johnson
USBDRIVE does not try to virtualize the sector sizes as others are suggesting here as a possibility -- I figure doing that has the potential to cause as many problems as the alternative... Maybe you could make that configurable, so people can experiment with virtual 512 byte sectors at their

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Eric Auer
Hi Bret, maybe virtual 512 byte sectors are actually not that evil: Imagine a NORMAL 4096 byte sector based FAT32 filesystem. Each cluster and each FAT will be a multiple of 4096 byte in size, as will be the boot and fsinfo sectors. In FAT32 the root directory is just any directory, so like all

[Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bertho Grandpied
Hi Bret, Not Bret, but I'll provide answers to 2 of your points. BPB CHS geometry differs - but does a disk with 4096 byte sectors allow CHS based access at all? I hope it does not. you can't preclude it, it may for compatibility sake (at the int 13h interface). (big big snipping) By

Re: [Freedos-user] FreeDOS 1.1 boot process ends with interrupt devide by zero and system halt

2012-01-15 Thread Ralph Deffke
Thanx all, but as I said its impossible to figure out what driver is causing the problem, the sequence doesn't seem to be logical to fix the problem. it crashes AFTER the boot has finished. I installed version 1,0 ( 0.87 beta ) with no problem. tx ralph

Re: [Freedos-user] FreeDOS 1.1 boot process ends with interrupt devide by zero and system halt

2012-01-15 Thread Kenneth J. Davis
On Jan 15, 2012 6:04 PM, Ralph Deffke ralph_def...@yahoo.de wrote: Thanx all, but as I said its impossible to figure out what driver is causing the problem, the sequence doesn't seem to be logical to fix the problem. it crashes AFTER the boot has finished. I installed version 1,0 ( 0.87

Re: [Freedos-user] FreeDOS 1.1 released

2012-01-15 Thread dos386
wish VMware's video feature would use standard codecs so something could be posted to Youtube or Please provide your movies in OGV or WebM files, not Loo-Tube. - It fails to find any HD (see middle shot) In the normal configurations or the dedication one? Both, but in normal configurations

Re: [Freedos-user] FreeDOS 1.1 boot process ends with interrupt devide by zero and system halt

2012-01-15 Thread dos386
Please try to empty FDCONFIG.SYS and FDAUTO.BAT, and re-add USEFUL things piece after piece ... and supply shot of the crash ... it crashes AFTER the boot has finished is NOT very informative. -- RSA(R) Conference 2012

Re: [Freedos-user] Re : Support for 4k byte sectors

2012-01-15 Thread Bret Johnson
maybe virtual 512 byte sectors are actually not that evil: Imagine a NORMAL 4096 byte sector based FAT32 filesystem. ... Actually they are, or at least potentially are, at least from a compatibility perspective. In the case of USB, the SCSI protocol is normally used. The sector size is not