[Freeipmi-devel] Re: Fw: ipmi-sensors and ipmimonitoring mismatch
Hey Won, The reason for what you're seeing is described in the ipmimonitoring manpage. --- Interpretation rules have not been written for all sensors permutations and types. Users may notice some sensors output in ipmi-sensors(8) do not output in ipmimonitoring. If sensor interpretation rules are needed, please contact the FreeIPMI maintainers. --- Looking at your sensors output below, there are three OEM sensors that I can't interpret b/c I don't know the interpretation rules for them. The Power Unit Device Install and Fan transition interpretations were recently added in 0.7.3. So if you update to atleast 0.7.3, those readings should show up in ipmimonitoring. As for why Temperature Sensors aren't showing up, this corner case for HP machines also appears to have been fixed in 0.7.3. Al --- On Fri, 4/3/09, Won De Erick won.der...@yahoo.com wrote: Hi, On HPDL 380G5 running FreeBSD 7.1, I tried installing FreeIPMI from ports. The currently ported version is, hpdl380-fbsd71r# bmc-info -V bmc-info - 0.7.1 Copyright (C) 2003-2008 FreeIPMI Core Team ... I noticed that some sensors displayed through 'ipmi-sensors' do not appear in 'ipmimonitoring'. hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmi-sensors 1: UID Light (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 2: Int. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 3: Ext.. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 4: Power Supply 1 (Power Supply): [Presence detected] 5: Power Supply 2 (Power Supply): [NA] 6: Power Supplies (Power Supply): [Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redundant] 8: VRM 1 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 9: VRM 2 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 10: Fan 1 (Fan): [transition to Running] 11: Fan 2 (Fan): [transition to Running] 12: Fan 3 (Fan): [transition to Running] 13: Fan 4 (Fan): [transition to Running] 14: Fan 5 (Fan): [transition to Running] 15: Fan 6 (Fan): [transition to Running] 16: Fans (Fan): [Fully Redundant] hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmimonitoring Record_ID | Sensor Name | Sensor Group | Monitoring Status| Sensor Units | Sensor Reading 4 | Power Supply 1 | Power Supply | Nominal | N/A | 'Presence detected' 6 | Power Supplies | Power Supply | Critical | N/A | 'Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redundant' 16 | Fans | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'Fully Redundant' 18 | Temp 1 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 36.00 19 | Temp 2 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 17.00 20 | Temp 3 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 21 | Temp 4 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 22 | Temp 5 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 46.00 23 | Temp 6 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 24 | Temp 7 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 Some fans are not appearing in the 'ipmimonitoring' output. See attached debug output. Thanks, Won -- Albert Chu ch...@llnl.gov Computer Scientist High Performance Systems Division Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory ___ Freeipmi-devel mailing list Freeipmi-devel@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-devel
[Freeipmi-devel] Re: Fw: ipmi-sensors and ipmimonitoring mismatch
--- On Fri, 4/3/09, Al Chu ch...@llnl.gov wrote: Hey Won, The reason for what you're seeing is described in the ipmimonitoring manpage. --- Interpretation rules have not been written for all sensors permutations and types. Users may notice some sensors output in ipmi-sensors(8) do not output in ipmimonitoring. If sensor interpretation rules are needed, please contact the FreeIPMI maintainers. --- Looking at your sensors output below, there are three OEM sensors that I can't interpret b/c I don't know the interpretation rules for them. The Power Unit Device Install and Fan transition interpretations were recently added in 0.7.3. So if you update to atleast 0.7.3, those readings should show up in ipmimonitoring. As for why Temperature Sensors aren't showing up, this corner case for HP machines also appears to have been fixed in 0.7..3. Thank you for the tip. I installed the latest, 0.7.6, instead. hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmi-sensors 1: UID Light (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 2: Int. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 3: Ext. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 4: Power Supply 1 (Power Supply): [Presence detected] 5: Power Supply 2 (Power Supply): [NA] 6: Power Supplies (Power Supply): [Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redun dant] 8: VRM 1 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 9: VRM 2 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 10: Fan 1 (Fan): [transition to Running] 11: Fan 2 (Fan): [transition to Running] 12: Fan 3 (Fan): [transition to Running] 13: Fan 4 (Fan): [transition to Running] 14: Fan 5 (Fan): [transition to Running] 15: Fan 6 (Fan): [transition to Running] 16: Fans (Fan): [Fully Redundant] 18: Temp 1 (Temperature): 35.00 C (NA/70.00): [OK] 19: Temp 2 (Temperature): 17.00 C (NA/39.00): [OK] 20: Temp 3 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 21: Temp 4 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 22: Temp 5 (Temperature): 46.00 C (NA/77.00): [OK] 23: Temp 6 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 24: Temp 7 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 25: Power Meter (Current): [Device Enabled] hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmimonitoring Record_ID | Sensor Name | Sensor Group | Monitoring Status| Sensor Units | Sensor Reading 4 | Power Supply 1 | Power Supply | Nominal | N/A | 'Presence detected' 6 | Power Supplies | Power Supply | Critical | N/A | 'Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redundant' 8 | VRM 1 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 9 | VRM 2 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 10 | Fan 1 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 11 | Fan 2 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 12 | Fan 3 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 13 | Fan 4 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 14 | Fan 5 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 15 | Fan 6 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 16 | Fans | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'Fully Redundant' 18 | Temp 1 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 35.00 19 | Temp 2 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 17.00 20 | Temp 3 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 21 | Temp 4 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 22 | Temp 5 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 46.00 23 | Temp 6 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 24 | Temp 7 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 hpdl380-fbsd71r# One thing left is how i can into the SEL. I tried this with other tools. None of them gave an output. :( The box is IPMI v2.0-compliant. I can see a lot of logs using iLO. Thanks, Won ___ Freeipmi-devel mailing list Freeipmi-devel@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-devel
[Freeipmi-devel] Re: Fw: ipmi-sensors and ipmimonitoring mismatch
Hey Won, One thing left is how i can into the SEL. I tried this with other tools. None of them gave an output. :( Do you mean you can't access the SEL in multiple IPMI software? Can you send me the --debug output from running ipmi-sel? Let's see what the problem is. Al On Fri, 2009-04-03 at 11:57 -0700, Won De Erick wrote: --- On Fri, 4/3/09, Al Chu ch...@llnl.gov wrote: Hey Won, The reason for what you're seeing is described in the ipmimonitoring manpage. --- Interpretation rules have not been written for all sensors permutations and types. Users may notice some sensors output in ipmi-sensors(8) do not output in ipmimonitoring. If sensor interpretation rules are needed, please contact the FreeIPMI maintainers. --- Looking at your sensors output below, there are three OEM sensors that I can't interpret b/c I don't know the interpretation rules for them. The Power Unit Device Install and Fan transition interpretations were recently added in 0.7.3. So if you update to atleast 0.7.3, those readings should show up in ipmimonitoring. As for why Temperature Sensors aren't showing up, this corner case for HP machines also appears to have been fixed in 0.7..3. Thank you for the tip. I installed the latest, 0.7.6, instead. hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmi-sensors 1: UID Light (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 2: Int. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 3: Ext. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 4: Power Supply 1 (Power Supply): [Presence detected] 5: Power Supply 2 (Power Supply): [NA] 6: Power Supplies (Power Supply): [Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redun dant] 8: VRM 1 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 9: VRM 2 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 10: Fan 1 (Fan): [transition to Running] 11: Fan 2 (Fan): [transition to Running] 12: Fan 3 (Fan): [transition to Running] 13: Fan 4 (Fan): [transition to Running] 14: Fan 5 (Fan): [transition to Running] 15: Fan 6 (Fan): [transition to Running] 16: Fans (Fan): [Fully Redundant] 18: Temp 1 (Temperature): 35.00 C (NA/70.00): [OK] 19: Temp 2 (Temperature): 17.00 C (NA/39.00): [OK] 20: Temp 3 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 21: Temp 4 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 22: Temp 5 (Temperature): 46.00 C (NA/77.00): [OK] 23: Temp 6 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 24: Temp 7 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 25: Power Meter (Current): [Device Enabled] hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmimonitoring Record_ID | Sensor Name | Sensor Group | Monitoring Status| Sensor Units | Sensor Reading 4 | Power Supply 1 | Power Supply | Nominal | N/A | 'Presence detected' 6 | Power Supplies | Power Supply | Critical | N/A | 'Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redundant' 8 | VRM 1 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 9 | VRM 2 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 10 | Fan 1 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 11 | Fan 2 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 12 | Fan 3 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 13 | Fan 4 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 14 | Fan 5 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 15 | Fan 6 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 16 | Fans | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'Fully Redundant' 18 | Temp 1 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 35.00 19 | Temp 2 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 17.00 20 | Temp 3 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 21 | Temp 4 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 22 | Temp 5 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 46.00 23 | Temp 6 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 24 | Temp 7 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 hpdl380-fbsd71r# One thing left is how i can into the SEL. I tried this with other tools. None of them gave an output. :( The box is IPMI v2.0-compliant. I can see a lot of logs using iLO. Thanks, Won -- Albert Chu ch...@llnl.gov Computer Scientist High Performance Systems Division Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory ___ Freeipmi-devel mailing list Freeipmi-devel@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-devel
[Freeipmi-devel] Re: Fw: ipmi-sensors and ipmimonitoring mismatch
Hi All, sending the debug output. Thanks, Won --- On Fri, 4/3/09, Al Chu ch...@llnl.gov wrote: Hey Won, One thing left is how i can into the SEL. I tried this with other tools. None of them gave an output. :( Do you mean you can't access the SEL in multiple IPMI software? Can you send me the --debug output from running ipmi-sel? Let's see what the problem is. Al On Fri, 2009-04-03 at 11:57 -0700, Won De Erick wrote: --- On Fri, 4/3/09, Al Chu ch...@llnl.gov wrote: Hey Won, The reason for what you're seeing is described in the ipmimonitoring manpage. --- Interpretation rules have not been written for all sensors permutations and types. Users may notice some sensors output in ipmi-sensors(8) do not output in ipmimonitoring. If sensor interpretation rules are needed, please contact the FreeIPMI maintainers. --- Looking at your sensors output below, there are three OEM sensors that I can't interpret b/c I don't know the interpretation rules for them. The Power Unit Device Install and Fan transition interpretations were recently added in 0.7.3. So if you update to atleast 0.7.3, those readings should show up in ipmimonitoring. As for why Temperature Sensors aren't showing up, this corner case for HP machines also appears to have been fixed in 0.7..3. Thank you for the tip. I installed the latest, 0.7.6, instead. hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmi-sensors 1: UID Light (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 2: Int. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 3: Ext. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 4: Power Supply 1 (Power Supply): [Presence detected] 5: Power Supply 2 (Power Supply): [NA] 6: Power Supplies (Power Supply): [Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redun dant] 8: VRM 1 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 9: VRM 2 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 10: Fan 1 (Fan): [transition to Running] 11: Fan 2 (Fan): [transition to Running] 12: Fan 3 (Fan): [transition to Running] 13: Fan 4 (Fan): [transition to Running] 14: Fan 5 (Fan): [transition to Running] 15: Fan 6 (Fan): [transition to Running] 16: Fans (Fan): [Fully Redundant] 18: Temp 1 (Temperature): 35.00 C (NA/70.00): [OK] 19: Temp 2 (Temperature): 17.00 C (NA/39.00): [OK] 20: Temp 3 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 21: Temp 4 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 22: Temp 5 (Temperature): 46.00 C (NA/77.00): [OK] 23: Temp 6 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 24: Temp 7 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 25: Power Meter (Current): [Device Enabled] hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmimonitoring Record_ID | Sensor Name | Sensor Group | Monitoring Status| Sensor Units | Sensor Reading 4 | Power Supply 1 | Power Supply | Nominal | N/A | 'Presence detected' 6 | Power Supplies | Power Supply | Critical | N/A | 'Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redu ndant' 8 | VRM 1 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 9 | VRM 2 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 10 | Fan 1 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 11 | Fan 2 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 12 | Fan 3 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 13 | Fan 4 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 14 | Fan 5 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 15 | Fan 6 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 16 | Fans | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'Fully Redundant' 18 | Temp 1 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 35.00 19 | Temp 2 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 17.00 20 | Temp 3 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 21 | Temp 4 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 22 | Temp 5 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 46.00 23 | Temp 6 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 24 | Temp 7 | Temperature | Nominal | C | 30.00 hpdl380-fbsd71r# One thing left is how i can into the SEL. I tried this with other tools. None of them gave an output. :( The box is IPMI v2.0-compliant. I can see a lot of logs using iLO. Thanks, Won -- Albert Chu ch...@llnl.gov Computer Scientist High Performance Systems Division Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmi-sel --debug = Get SDR Repository Info Request = [ 20h] = cmd[ 8b] = Get SDR Repository Info Response = [ 20h] = cmd[ 8b] [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] [ 1h] = sdr_version_major[ 4b] [ 5h] = sdr_version_minor[ 4b] [ 1Ah] = record_count[16b] [h] = free_space[16b] [h] =
[Freeipmi-devel] Re: Fw: ipmi-sensors and ipmimonitoring mismatch
Hey Won, This output looks familiar, I think I have worked on this before with another FreeIPMI user ... = Reserve SEL Request = [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] = Reserve SEL Response = [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] [ C1h] = comp_code[ 8b] ipmi_cmd_reserve_sel: bad completion code: command invalid/not supported So this is a bug on HP's part, but shouldn't really be a problem b/c I have code to work around it (you can tell b/c there is more output :-) ... = Get SEL Entry Request = [ 43h] = cmd[ 8b] [ 0h] = reservation_id[16b] [ 0h] = record_id[16b] [ 0h] = offset_into_record[ 8b] [ FFh] = bytes_to_read[ 8b] = Get SEL Entry Response = [ 43h] = cmd[ 8b] [ CBh] = comp_code[ 8b] CBh = sensor not present Something seems amiss in the HP IPMI. Do you have any HP software that works? Maybe it only works for HP software and none of the open source software out there. Al On Fri, 2009-04-03 at 18:21 -0700, Won De Erick wrote: Hi All, sending the debug output. Thanks, Won --- On Fri, 4/3/09, Al Chu ch...@llnl.gov wrote: Hey Won, One thing left is how i can into the SEL. I tried this with other tools. None of them gave an output. :( Do you mean you can't access the SEL in multiple IPMI software? Can you send me the --debug output from running ipmi-sel? Let's see what the problem is. Al On Fri, 2009-04-03 at 11:57 -0700, Won De Erick wrote: --- On Fri, 4/3/09, Al Chu ch...@llnl.gov wrote: Hey Won, The reason for what you're seeing is described in the ipmimonitoring manpage. --- Interpretation rules have not been written for all sensors permutations and types. Users may notice some sensors output in ipmi-sensors(8) do not output in ipmimonitoring. If sensor interpretation rules are needed, please contact the FreeIPMI maintainers. --- Looking at your sensors output below, there are three OEM sensors that I can't interpret b/c I don't know the interpretation rules for them. The Power Unit Device Install and Fan transition interpretations were recently added in 0.7.3. So if you update to atleast 0.7.3, those readings should show up in ipmimonitoring. As for why Temperature Sensors aren't showing up, this corner case for HP machines also appears to have been fixed in 0.7..3. Thank you for the tip. I installed the latest, 0.7.6, instead. hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmi-sensors 1: UID Light (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 2: Int. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 3: Ext. Health LED (OEM Reserved): [OEM State = h] 4: Power Supply 1 (Power Supply): [Presence detected] 5: Power Supply 2 (Power Supply): [NA] 6: Power Supplies (Power Supply): [Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redun dant] 8: VRM 1 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 9: VRM 2 (Power Unit): [Device Inserted/Device Present] 10: Fan 1 (Fan): [transition to Running] 11: Fan 2 (Fan): [transition to Running] 12: Fan 3 (Fan): [transition to Running] 13: Fan 4 (Fan): [transition to Running] 14: Fan 5 (Fan): [transition to Running] 15: Fan 6 (Fan): [transition to Running] 16: Fans (Fan): [Fully Redundant] 18: Temp 1 (Temperature): 35.00 C (NA/70.00): [OK] 19: Temp 2 (Temperature): 17.00 C (NA/39.00): [OK] 20: Temp 3 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 21: Temp 4 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 22: Temp 5 (Temperature): 46.00 C (NA/77.00): [OK] 23: Temp 6 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 24: Temp 7 (Temperature): 30.00 C (NA/127.00): [OK] 25: Power Meter (Current): [Device Enabled] hpdl380-fbsd71r# ipmimonitoring Record_ID | Sensor Name | Sensor Group | Monitoring Status| Sensor Units | Sensor Reading 4 | Power Supply 1 | Power Supply | Nominal | N/A | 'Presence detected' 6 | Power Supplies | Power Supply | Critical | N/A | 'Non-redundant:Sufficient Resources from Redu ndant' 8 | VRM 1 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 9 | VRM 2 | Power Unit | Nominal | N/A | 'Device Inserted/Device Present' 10 | Fan 1 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 11 | Fan 2 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 12 | Fan 3 | Fan | Nominal | N/A | 'transition to Running' 13 | Fan 4 | Fan | Nominal | N/A |
[Freeipmi-devel] Re: Fw: ipmi-sensors and ipmimonitoring mismatch
--- On Sat, 4/4/09, Al Chu11 ch...@llnl.gov wrote: Hey Won, This output looks familiar, I think I have worked on this before with another FreeIPMI user ... CBh = sensor not present Something seems amiss in the HP IPMI. Do you have any HP software that works? Maybe it only works for HP software and none of the open source software out there. I am using an 60-day evaluation edition of HP iLO 2 (embedded). The iLO 2 is as good as an out-of management system. I am accessing it via the dedicated iLO management port (Ethernet). I should at least want to manage the BMC via in-band. Thanks, Won ___ Freeipmi-devel mailing list Freeipmi-devel@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-devel
