Re: [Freesurfer] Comparing lists of activated regions between taskctrl contrasts

2015-08-28 Thread Douglas Greve
On 8/27/15 1:13 PM, Francesco Puccettone wrote: Hello all, I have seen several (older) papers that draw conclusions about the implication of a brain region in a given task by using the following logic: region X was activated in the contrast /taskAbaseline/, but not in the contrast

Re: [Freesurfer] Comparing lists of activated regions between taskctrl contrasts

2015-08-28 Thread Douglas Greve
On 8/27/15 1:20 PM, Francesco Puccettone wrote: Sorry, forgot to add one additional (related) question: is it ever correct to say for region Y, the activations found for taskA were smaller than for taskB just based on the two contrasts /taskAbaseline /and /taskBbaseline/? Or is it necessary

[Freesurfer] Comparing lists of activated regions between taskctrl contrasts

2015-08-27 Thread Francesco Puccettone
Hello all, I have seen several (older) papers that draw conclusions about the implication of a brain region in a given task by using the following logic: region X was activated in the contrast *taskAbaseline*, but not in the contrast *taskBbaseline*; therefore, region X is implicated in/essential

Re: [Freesurfer] Comparing lists of activated regions between taskctrl contrasts

2015-08-27 Thread Francesco Puccettone
Sorry, forgot to add one additional (related) question: is it ever correct to say for region Y, the activations found for taskA were smaller than for taskB just based on the two contrasts *taskAbaseline *and *taskBbaseline*? Or is it necessary that taskA and taskB be contrasted directly to be

Re: [Freesurfer] Comparing lists of activated regions between taskctrl contrasts

2015-08-27 Thread Watson, Christopher
of activated regions between taskctrl contrasts Sorry, forgot to add one additional (related) question: is it ever correct to say for region Y, the activations found for taskA were smaller than for taskB just based on the two contrasts taskAbaseline and taskBbaseline? Or is it necessary that taskA