Re: [FRIAM] So, *Are* We Alone?

2012-04-05 Thread Douglas Roberts
I guess I must have spoiled your game somewhat by turning out to be barely lukewarm regarding the charms of induction, NIck. Well, what can I say, except that one person's fascination is, well, one person's fascination. --Doug On Wed, Apr 4, 2012 at 11:53 PM, Nicholas Thompson

Re: [FRIAM] So, *Are* We Alone?

2012-04-05 Thread Sarbajit Roy
'Hydrogen is a light, odorless gas, which, given enough time, turns into people.' Hydrogen sulfide is another gas entirely. On 4/5/12, Douglas Roberts d...@parrot-farm.net wrote: I guess I must have spoiled your game somewhat by turning out to be barely lukewarm regarding the charms of

Re: [FRIAM] So, *Are* We Alone?

2012-04-05 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Doug, Well, when you are talking about motivations, you are talking about my so-called area of expertise. But I don't think we have been talking about motivations. I think we have been talking about LOGIC. The implicit reasoning that HAS to underlie a position to make it make sense.

Re: [FRIAM] So, *Are* We Alone?

2012-04-05 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Sarbajit, Before I forget, induction is coming to a conclusion about the character of a class through amassing instances of that class. (Collecting swans that are white to show that all swans are white.) Abduction is amassing properties of an individual to show that that individual is