Re: [FRIAM] natalism

2023-10-12 Thread glen
Yep. And the same is true with Frank's trolling about the well-definedness of truth. Consistency, like reduction and isolation, is a fantastic tool but a bad master. When Hanson argues that we must continue to have babies or risk the halt of innovation, it's with a fixed backdrop, worldview. Ad

Re: [FRIAM] natalism

2023-10-12 Thread Steve Smith
Glen - I think I agree with this spirit...  and the invocation of a high-dimensional (but finitely so) landscape is not only the constraints we live in, but in some sense the ones we *choose* to live in?   I think excess/sloppy meaning might be another term for a local/temporary increase (or

Re: [FRIAM] natalism

2023-10-12 Thread glen
Well, *if* one is constrained to inhabiting attractors to begin with, then a mechanism for hopping between attractors is a "good thing". But I'd argue that this is a mere band-aide, treating the symptom rather than the cause. The real disorder is the tendency to inhabit attractors ... or perhap

Re: [FRIAM] natalism

2023-10-09 Thread Steve Smith
Glen - In the spirit of succinctness (succinctity?) my intuition aligns with your argument here about the relevance/utility of flex/slop...   I think this is a corollary to Deacon's "absential" but to pursue it more formally would puncture the walls of my aspired /succintity/. At the risk of

Re: [FRIAM] natalism

2023-10-09 Thread glen
As usual, there's too much in your post for me to follow a thread. But I can cherry-pick this one: affect - or what it is to be about/for something. An option is to think in terms of soft types such that the lower order objects over which the higher order operators ... uh, operate, have some "f

Re: [FRIAM] natalism

2023-10-06 Thread Steve Smith
https://www.overcomingbias.com/p/shrinking-economies-dont-innovate I am fond of this style of (counter)thinking to the growth/innovation topic: Economics for the Future: Beyond the Superorganism It doesn't really argue the point (natalism and other quantitative measures of growth?) direc

[FRIAM] natalism

2023-10-06 Thread glen
https://www.overcomingbias.com/p/shrinking-economies-dont-innovate There's something about this rhetoric that seems to rely on hierarchical separation, the separability of levels. I mean, obviously, if we draw a hard boundary around "innovation" such that it only contains things we human organi