[fw-general] Zend_Controller_Action::init() (Was: SVN 2077: Getting parameters from route)

2006-12-05 Thread Nick Lo
Hi Matthew, init() happens at object instantiation, which happens before preDispatch() -- it's basically provided so that you don't need to override the constructor, and thus possibly forget to set the request, response, and other parameters (as you discovered the hard way). It does seem like

Re: [fw-general] Zend_Controller_Action::init() (Was: SVN 2077: Getting parameters from route)

2006-12-05 Thread Matthew Ratzloff
In other words it will need to be a warning. That is where I feel that init() is unintuitive and most people (I say with hesitation being a self elected representative) would expect to go with the constructor for this task. Why not declare Zend_Controller_Action::__construct() as final?

Re: [fw-general] Zend_Controller_Action::init() (Was: SVN 2077: Getting parameters from route)

2006-12-05 Thread Nick Lo
Hi Matt, Yes, that would stop people possibly forget[ing] to set the request, response, and other parameters, however, it would also mean closing off the constructor completely and replacing it's initialisation functionality with the init() method. All that is done because the response