I just got a copy of James VanderKam, From Joshua to Caiphas: High Priests 
after the Exile (Fortress & Van Gorcum, 2004). Though I haven't read it all, 
it so far appears to be Jim's typically excellent work. Let me quote from the 
Alexander Jannaeus section (p.336):

"It is surely possible that the attitude of the covenanters at Qumran toward 
the Hasmonean rulers changed as circumstances did; nevertheless, the other 
evidence on this matter shows only negative views about the reigning house. In 
this respect, the approach to 4Q448 defended by E. Main seems to point in a 
more helpful direction. According to Main, a study of the biblical usage of 
the phrasing found in line 1  (WR (L  demonstrates that the prayer asks God to 
fight against King Jonathan but to bless his people."

Yes. VanderKam also cites Lemaire. To those three names (Main, Lemaire, and 
VanderKam) we can add Penner, Lorein, Harrington/Strugnell, (and me).

I suggest it is time to focus on the chronology of "wicked priest" Alexander 
Jannaeus and "teacher of righteousness" Judah the Essene.

best,
Stephen Goranson

_______________________________________________
g-Megillot mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mailman.McMaster.CA/mailman/listinfo/g-megillot

Reply via email to