Re: [m5-dev] syscall tracer

2009-01-31 Thread nathan binkert
I think I'm missing the high level overview of what this thread is about, but I do have one comment To help find that seg fault, I'd suggest going into the kernel and placing m5_exit() calls in arch/x86/mm/fault.c in the do_page_fault() where the kernel sends a SIGSEGV to user code and that'll

Re: [m5-dev] syscall tracer

2009-01-31 Thread Gabe Black
Another thing that could be nice for debugging is hacking ld.so a little bit so that it passes the symbols to M5 with the add_symbol instruction. You'd of course not want all instances of ld.so running to do this, so you'd want to be able to have a set of programs or PIDs or something that

Re: [m5-dev] syscall tracer

2009-01-31 Thread nathan binkert
It would be nice to hack the kernels elf loader to do something similar as well. Both could provide be sort of an overlay symbol table you'd pull in and out on task switches. I like these ideas, but unfortunately the binaries I'm dealing with in my disk image don't seem to have any symbols

[m5-dev] interrupt lines

2009-01-31 Thread Gabe Black
I'm revamping the way I've had interrupt lines implemented in my patch queue and I have a few questions. First I'll describe how it used to (and does in the head) work. There is an interrupt pin which knows what object it belongs to and what its index is. To connect the timer to the PIC's

Re: [m5-dev] interrupt lines

2009-01-31 Thread Ali Saidi
This seems like a lot of complexity for not much gain. Remember, that we don't have to do exactly what the real hardware does. We can have PIC/IO APIC device that handles both modes. While it needs to appear to the OS in the correct fashion, it doesn't need to actually be exactly the same

Re: [m5-dev] interrupt lines

2009-01-31 Thread Gabe Black
Those later schemes I agree are overly complex. The PIC and IO APIC aren't two different modes, they're two different resources the OS can use at the same time. I think Linux attempted to do just that to try to work around some aspect of my hardware that wasn't behaving right, although their