Hi,
On Fri, Nov 22, 2019 at 9:47 PM Craig Russell wrote:
> ...I believe that the current cookbook recommendations need an update. [1] ...
Thank you Craig and others for these suggestions, I have incorporated
them as follows:
-Added a new "Two-phase vote on Podling Releases" to keep the
Hi Bertrand,
> So I'd say "votes from the podling dev list should be carried over to the
> Incubator PMC vote, by explicitly mentioned them and including a link to the
> corresponding vote tally (from lists.apache.org) in the Incubator PMC vote
> message”.
From my understanding, it means
Hi Justin,
I totally agree with you. Presenting votes and names of none-IMPCs not only
helps other IMPCs check and vote, but is respectful for everyone’s effort.
Regards,
Trista
Juan Pan
panj...@apache.org
Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere
On 11/25/2019 15:13，Justin Mclean wrote：
Hi,
> So I'd say "votes from the podling dev list should be carried over to
> the Incubator PMC vote, by explicitly mentioned them and including a
> link to the corresponding vote tally (from lists.apache.org) in the
> Incubator PMC vote message”.
+1 As usual Bertrand you put it more eloquently
Hi,
On Fri, Nov 22, 2019 at 9:47 PM Craig Russell wrote:
> ...2. Votes on the dev list should automatically carry over to the general
> list...
I disagree with making this automatic.
It's fine for whoever starts the IPMC vote to indicate that dev list
votes carry over, including a link to
Hi,
> How about votes from PPMCs in dev@? As votes from PPMCs are unbinding in
> general@, release manages would ignore those votes from dev@, and do not
> present their names and votes when summarizing? Or on the contrary?
IMO it nice to know how many votes it got on the devlist that were not
Hi,
+1 from me, as long as the podling dev list IPMC votes are clearly indicated in
the vote mail to the incubator general list.
Thanks,
Justin
-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org
For additional
I believe that the current cookbook recommendations need an update. [1]
1. "Binding" should always refer to IPMC members' votes. This is a source of
confusion for many podling communities.
2. Votes on the dev list should automatically carry over to the general list.
Assuming that there is no
