Re: [RESULT][VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-21 Thread Malcolm Edgar
Thank you all for your support. regards Malcolm Edgar On Wed, Oct 21, 2009 at 9:44 PM, Bob Schellink wrote: > Bob Schellink wrote: > > >> I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click >> as a Top Level Project to the Board. >> > > > The vote has passed with 10 +1 votes

[RESULT][VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-21 Thread Bob Schellink
Bob Schellink wrote: I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click as a Top Level Project to the Board. The vote has passed with 10 +1 votes and no 0 or -1 votes. Here are the votes: +1 Andrus Adamchik +1 Jim Jagielski +1 Will Glass-Husain +1 Craig Russe

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-20 Thread Bob Schellink
Jukka Zitting wrote: I assume he'll be a candidate also for PMC membership if he keeps up contributing. Yes, every few months we'll review our current committers for PMC membership. Kind regards Bob - To unsubscribe, e-m

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-20 Thread Jukka Zitting
Hi, On Tue, Oct 20, 2009 at 3:16 AM, Bob Schellink wrote: > Adrian has only been given svn permissions in mid September and he has made > some commits[1]. Hmm, I guess his commit notifications haven't been moderated through, as I couldn't see him on the commit list archive. I assume he'll be a c

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-19 Thread Bob Schellink
Hi Jukka, Adrian has only been given svn permissions in mid September and he has made some commits[1]. As Malcolm mentioned we're currently in feature freeze for our next release so that does put a break on things. For the next Click release most of the tasks are assigned to him [2]. Also note

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-19 Thread Malcolm Edgar
Hi All, we have been in somewhat of a holding pattern with the next release 2.1.0 wanting for the graduate from the Incubator so we can coordinate a publicity push (which will grow the community). There is also a book in the wings written by Frederic Daoud also waiting for the project to graduate s

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-19 Thread Jukka Zitting
Hi, -0 I notice you added a new committer some months ago, but he hasn't committed anything since and is not included in the proposed PMC. In fact I can't see any new active committers joining the team since the project started incubation. You do have a healthy-looking patch queue, so I'm wonderi

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-19 Thread Kevan Miller
+1 --kevan On Oct 17, 2009, at 9:39 PM, Bob Schellink wrote: Hi all, The Apache Click community has voted to request graduation from the Incubator as a new TLP [1][2]. I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click as a Top Level Project to the Board. Please cast

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-19 Thread Jim Jagielski
On Oct 18, 2009, at 5:06 PM, Henning Schmiedehausen wrote: Hello Jim, many Apache projects have shown that small PMCs can work as effectively (or sometimes even more effective) than bigger PMCs. I didn't say I *was* worried... I just asked should I be... ;) ---

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-19 Thread Martijn Dashorst
+1, congrats and good luck! Martijn On Sun, Oct 18, 2009 at 3:39 AM, Bob Schellink wrote: > Hi all, > > The Apache Click community has voted to request graduation from the > Incubator as a new TLP [1][2]. > > I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click as > a Top Lev

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-18 Thread William A. Rowe, Jr.
Bob Schellink wrote: > > I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click > as a Top Level Project to the Board. > > Please cast your vote: > > [X] +1 to recommend Click's graduation - To unsubscribe, e

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-18 Thread Niall Pemberton
+1 Niall On Sun, Oct 18, 2009 at 2:39 AM, Bob Schellink wrote: > Hi all, > > The Apache Click community has voted to request graduation from the > Incubator as a new TLP [1][2]. > > I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click as > a Top Level Project to the Board. >

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-18 Thread Henning Schmiedehausen
Hello Jim, many Apache projects have shown that small PMCs can work as effectively (or sometimes even more effective) than bigger PMCs. In a small PMC, the sense of responsibility and ownership is different from a 20+ members PMC. I feel that the Click community has gone tremendously well through

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-18 Thread Craig L Russell
+1 The initial PMC may be small but as long as the community works well, continues to attract users and committers, and follows the Apache Way, I have no issues. Craig On Oct 17, 2009, at 6:39 PM, Bob Schellink wrote: Hi all, The Apache Click community has voted to request graduation fr

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-18 Thread Will Glass-Husain
+1 I've been significantly impressed with the quality of the Click project from both a community and a code standpoint. This is a small but innovative project that illustrates the benefits of the Apache way. Besides Will and Henning's Apache experience, Malcolm Edgar is also involved in Apache C

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-18 Thread Jim Jagielski
Should I be concerned that the initial size of the PMC is "just" 5 people? Even so, +1 On Oct 17, 2009, at 9:39 PM, Bob Schellink wrote: Hi all, The Apache Click community has voted to request graduation from the Incubator as a new TLP [1][2]. I would like to start a vote to recommend the g

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-18 Thread Andrus Adamchik
+1 On Oct 18, 2009, at 4:39 AM, Bob Schellink wrote: Hi all, The Apache Click community has voted to request graduation from the Incubator as a new TLP [1][2]. I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click as a Top Level Project to the Board. Please cast your vo

[VOTE] Graduate Click as an Apache TLP

2009-10-17 Thread Bob Schellink
Hi all, The Apache Click community has voted to request graduation from the Incubator as a new TLP [1][2]. I would like to start a vote to recommend the graduation of Apache Click as a Top Level Project to the Board. Please cast your vote: [ ] +1 to recommend Click's graduation [ ] 0 don't c