Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-15 Thread Roland Weber
Hi Henri, - A CLA on file from the revival candidate. (resurrector) The mentor should guide them through a few patches to show they are committed, then we can make them a committer. I don't think there's any reason to do CLAs without also making them committers. I'm not sure we need to

Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-14 Thread Roland Weber
Hi Julius, If someone is interested in taking over a truly inactive project, maybe they should fork and start their own SVN repository from their own domain. The person should make it clear that their fork is in no way sanctioned by Apache. That would be OK for projects that are, as you

Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-14 Thread Henri Yandell
On 2/14/07, Roland Weber [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Here is my take on a revival procedure... Pre-precondition. We need to define what is inactive and place it in such a state. Dormant seems a favourite word. In the recent board report for the Commons components, we've gone with Inactive to

Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-14 Thread Julius Davies
After reading the followups, -1 to my original idea! :-) One funny thought: I love having inactive jars in my classpath. It's the active jars that give me all the headaches! -- yours, Julius Davies 416-652-0183 http://juliusdavies.ca/

Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-11 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Hi Julius (learning here :), Thanx for the comprehensive and well thought out mail.. Julius Davies wrote: Thanks for your reply, Martin! To reiterate (hopefully more clearly this time), I see two dilemmas and two problems: Dilemma #1: -- You can't stop

Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-10 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Hi everyone, Moving this from the private list to general (this is actually a spin of from a thread about adding a committer to an inactive project, hence that it was on private). Definition list : Inactive project = a project that has no *developer* community. The Apache Way : To become

Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-10 Thread Julius Davies
Hi, Martin, and Everyone, If someone is interested in taking over a truly inactive project, maybe they should fork and start their own SVN repository from their own domain. The person should make it clear that their fork is in no way sanctioned by Apache. The only responsibility Apache might

Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-10 Thread Martin van den Bemt
Hi Julies, Julius Davies wrote: Hi, Martin, and Everyone, If someone is interested in taking over a truly inactive project, maybe they should fork and start their own SVN repository from their own domain. The person should make it clear that their fork is in no way sanctioned by Apache.

Re: Howto revive inactive projects ?

2007-02-10 Thread Julius Davies
Thanks for your reply, Martin! To reiterate (hopefully more clearly this time), I see two dilemmas and two problems: Dilemma #1: -- You can't stop people from forking. Forking is the lowest barrier way for a committer-less community to revive an inactive project.