Re: [gentoo-dev] rfc: [QA] Ban policy introduction SLIPUP
Hello folks, I apologize to everyone for sending this proposal before it was finished. It was not voted on by the QA team hence it was not an official proposal by the QA team. There was probably some misunderstanding in communication. After we finish the official draft and it is accepted by QA team members, we will be very happy to accept comments on the mailing list in the future. Thank you for understanding On behalf of QA team, Amy Liffey On 07/30/2018 10:03 AM, Dirkjan Ochtman wrote: > On Mon, Jul 30, 2018 at 8:52 AM Guilherme Amadio <mailto:ama...@gentoo.org>> wrote: > > If you introduce penalties for breaking prefix as well, I'm afraid many > people will be unnecessarily penalized. I think that such penalties are > counter productive in most cases. If someone is really being careless it > might make sense to get some warning and lose commit access temporarily. > If someone made a simple mistake that can be easily fixed, like version > bumping a package that starts to fail in some corner case, then > punishment doesn't make much sense. > > > The proposed policy already mentions that people will only be punished > after two warnings. This seems enough for me -- if people keep breaking > stuff despite warnings, a little penalty is probably a good thing. > > The proposed policy already goes out of its way to require two warnings > for "independent" breakage, but it's not entirely clear what independent > means here. If you commit three breakages that are technically unrelated > on the same day, then you probably shouldn't be banned immediately. So I > would suggest also making clear that the warnings should be sent at > least a few days apart and that an initial penalty cannot happen until a > few days apart the second warning. > > That said, I agree with those who are saying that breaking things should > be obvious, things like ignoring repoman and/or other CI messaging. If > the breakage is non-obvious and hard to spot locally, then we should > instead invest in tooling to make it more obvious. By "ignoring" here I > do mean that there needs to be a reasonable timeout -- sometimes if I > commit a change and get a CI alert after a few hours, it might be tricky > due to work/family/whatever concerns to fix it within, say, 24 hours. > > Regards, > > Dirkjan signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Last rites app-misc/eid-viewer-bin
# Amy Liffey (16 May 2018) # Obsolete and not used anymore replaced by app-crypt/eid-mw. # Requested by maintainer Vincent Hardy # Removal in 30 days. app-misc/eid-viewer-bin
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: dev-java/boilerpipe dev-python/django-two-factor-auth dev-python/cfgio dev-python/phonenumbers dev-python/django-opensearch dev-python/yubiotp dev-python/django-otp dev-python/shortuuid dev-python/twilio dev-python/django-phonenumber-field dev-python/django-otp-yubikey net-analyzer/nagios-check_linux_bonding net-misc/openvpn-auth-ldap dev-libs/grok Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: net-libs/pacparser net-fs/cvmfs app-arch/brotli dev-util/conan dev-util/cmt dev-libs/starpu Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: x11-libs/libast dev-cpp/gmock sys-boot/cromwell-bin sys-boot/cromwell sys-boot/raincoat dev-vcs/pwclient dev-vcs/cvsync app-cdr/extract-xiso app-cdr/xdvdfs-tools www-apache/mod_h2 app-crypt/osslsigncode app-crypt/crackpkcs12 sys-auth/pam_bioapi sys-auth/bioapi sys-auth/google-authenticator sys-auth/tfm-fingerprint dev-python/pystdf dev-python/python-evdev app-portage/portage-utils sys-apps/i2c-tools sys-apps/iotools sys-apps/superiotool app-editors/curses-hexedit app-editors/nano net-libs/libhtp net-libs/nghttp2 app-misc/evtest app-misc/pax-utils app-doc/linkers-and-loaders app-doc/phrack app-doc/linux-gazette app-doc/phrack-all app-doc/linux-gazette-all app-text/nfoview net-misc/tlsdate net-misc/ssvnc net-misc/gsutil net-misc/chrome-remote-desktop dev-lang/closure-compiler-bin app-mobilephone/cobex app-arch/cksfv app-arch/lcab app-arch/funzix sys-fs/libfat net-wireless/neard sys-libs/libseccomp sys-libs/libnih dev-util/stressapptest x11-terms/eterm dev-libs/libsolv dev-libs/liblzw dev-libs/zziplib dev-libs/crossguid Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello all, The following packages are up for grabs: app-cdr/cdw app-misc/figlet app-text/tree dev-lang/nasm dev-lang/blassic dev-lang/clojure app-admin/syslog-ng dev-libs/eventlog Cheers, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: sci-geosciences/gmapcatcher dev-util/webstorm Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: x11-wm/afterstep mail-client/nmh dev-util/wsta dev-util/bats app-admin/yadm Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: net-p2p/litecoin-qt net-p2p/litecoind sys-process/nmon Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: app-admin/localepurge net-misc/ytalk Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello, The following packages are up for grabs: net-analyzer/nagios-check_fail2ban net-analyzer//nagios-check_pidfile Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Package up for grabs
The following package is up for grabs: dev-lang/gforth Best regards, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grabs
Hello all, some new orphaned packages: x11-wm/fvwm app-text/pdfsandwich dev-cpp/gtest net-misc/wicd dev-lua/luvit Cheers, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Packages up for grasp
Hello, some packages for grasp who is interested: app-emulation/vpcs dev-python/aiohttp-cors dev-python/kiwisolver dev-python/python-zipstream dev-python/raven net-misc/gns3-converter net-misc/gns3-gui net-misc/gns3-server net-misc/leapcast Cheers, Amy Liffey signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
