Re: [gentoo-dev] about the stable requests

2015-02-02 Thread Jeroen Roovers
On Sat, 31 Jan 2015 14:40:47 +0100
Agostino Sarubbo a...@gentoo.org wrote:

 Looks like everyone is file stable requests with own 
 rules or better to say is without common rules.

What is the problem?

 I'd like to document a sort of best-practice(s) on 
 our wiki.

 Who want to partecipate?

It's a wiki. Nothing is stopping you from drafting anything and then
proposing to make that into something canonical.


 jer



[gentoo-dev] about the stable requests

2015-01-31 Thread Agostino Sarubbo
Looks like everyone is file stable requests with own 
rules or better to say is without common rules.
I'd like to document a sort of best-practice(s) on 
our wiki.

Who want to partecipate?

-- 
Agostino Sarubbo
Gentoo Linux Developer


Re: [gentoo-dev] about the stable requests

2015-01-31 Thread hasufell
Agostino Sarubbo:
 Looks like everyone is file stable requests with own 
 rules or better to say is without common rules.
 I'd like to document a sort of best-practice(s) on 
 our wiki.
 
 Who want to partecipate?
 

I don't think we need specific rules here. Packages and upstreams are
different, so the time and circumstance of stabilizations can and should
differ.

But what makes sense is to document what the maintainers have to take
care of (or in other words what is out of scope for arch teams) like:
* test reverse deps
* test packages with USE=-* and USE=+all +use +flags
* something else?



Re: [gentoo-dev] about the stable requests

2015-01-31 Thread Brian Dolbec
On Sat, 31 Jan 2015 14:40:47 +0100
Agostino Sarubbo a...@gentoo.org wrote:

 Looks like everyone is file stable requests with own 
 rules or better to say is without common rules.
 I'd like to document a sort of best-practice(s) on 
 our wiki.
 
 Who want to partecipate?
 

My recent etc-proposals bump and re-Stabilization request for the
EAPI/distutils-r1 change.  Is that one you prefer we just handle and
not add to your list?

I wouldn't have for just the berlios url changes.

-- 
Brian Dolbec dolsen