Re: [gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
Petteri Räty wrote:
Marius Mauch kirjoitti:
On Mon, 23 Apr 2007 23:45:48 +0200
dju` [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
eerror Your ${package} package has been built without
eerror ${func} support, please enable the '${use_flag}' USE flag
and
eerror re-emerge ${package}.
elog You can enable this USE flag either globally in
/etc/make.conf,
elog or just for specific packages in /etc/portage/package.use.
die ${package} missing ${func} support
A little detail about elog: You should not use different elog functions
(eerror, elog, ewarn, ...) within the same message as they may appear
out of order in the final log (e.g. the elog lines might appear before
the eerror lines). This is because messages of the same loglevel and in
the same phase are grouped together. It's an implementation detail that
might be changed in future versions, but for now you'll have to live
with it.
Also I don't see much use in explaining how to enable a use flag inside
ebuilds, at most there should be a pointer to the real documentation
IMO.
Marius
Any updates on this?
[EMAIL PROTECTED] /usr/portage/eclass $ grep built_with_use_die -r .
[EMAIL PROTECTED] /usr/portage/eclass $
I for one would use it if it existed.
Regards,
Petteri
built_with_use sys-apps/pciutils zlib die You need to build
sys-apps/pciutils without zlib
WHY do we need YET another function for such a simple construct?
built_with_use is already available and very powerful.
For example, HAL does..
built_with_use --missing false sys-apps/pciutils zlib
If the USE flag is missing entirely, it'll treat it like it's disabled
because old versions didn't have the zlib USE flag and didn't gzip their
data. Some packages it might be the other way around so you can pass
true instead.
Adding built_with_use_die is utterly pointless.
--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list
Re: [gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
Marius Mauch kirjoitti:
On Mon, 23 Apr 2007 23:45:48 +0200
dju` [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
eerror Your ${package} package has been built without
eerror ${func} support, please enable the '${use_flag}' USE flag
and
eerror re-emerge ${package}.
elog You can enable this USE flag either globally in
/etc/make.conf,
elog or just for specific packages in /etc/portage/package.use.
die ${package} missing ${func} support
A little detail about elog: You should not use different elog functions
(eerror, elog, ewarn, ...) within the same message as they may appear
out of order in the final log (e.g. the elog lines might appear before
the eerror lines). This is because messages of the same loglevel and in
the same phase are grouped together. It's an implementation detail that
might be changed in future versions, but for now you'll have to live
with it.
Also I don't see much use in explaining how to enable a use flag inside
ebuilds, at most there should be a pointer to the real documentation
IMO.
Marius
Any updates on this?
[EMAIL PROTECTED] /usr/portage/eclass $ grep built_with_use_die -r .
[EMAIL PROTECTED] /usr/portage/eclass $
I for one would use it if it existed.
Regards,
Petteri
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: [gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Lars Weiler a écrit : * dju` [EMAIL PROTECTED] [07/04/23 23:45 +0200]: # Generate a standard error message for missing USE flags # in existing packages, and die. I dislike that an emerge process dies when a use-flag is not set (okay, it will die otherwise later with the package that needs the dependency with that special use-flag built). It should be better to break with an appropriate message _before_ anything will be compiled. Let's say, directly after portage has calculated the dependencies. Your proposal looks like a quick fix for a feature portage can't handle yet. But your attached list of packages which already use that behaviour is already quite long and so you better should convince the portage-devs to include built-use-flags into the dependency calculation. Yes it's a quick fix, just as built_with_use() is. But before Portage know how to handle USE deps, is it worth adding built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass and possibly fixing a lot of ebuilds ? - -- Julien Allanos (dju`) -BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE- Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (MingW32) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org iD8DBQFGLbsngzJGpDypHxkRArTHAJ9RJIPEQjgqmv6i5/op4xqawoq2KgCgx3bG 7hSshEgG5HRVV5kD6FY1KyE= =K8xP -END PGP SIGNATURE- -- [EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list
Re: [gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
On Mon, 23 Apr 2007 23:45:48 +0200
dju` [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
eerror Your ${package} package has been built without
eerror ${func} support, please enable the '${use_flag}' USE flag and
eerror re-emerge ${package}.
elog You can enable this USE flag either globally in /etc/make.conf,
elog or just for specific packages in /etc/portage/package.use.
die ${package} missing ${func} support
A little detail about elog: You should not use different elog functions
(eerror, elog, ewarn, ...) within the same message as they may appear
out of order in the final log (e.g. the elog lines might appear before
the eerror lines). This is because messages of the same loglevel and in
the same phase are grouped together. It's an implementation detail that
might be changed in future versions, but for now you'll have to live
with it.
Also I don't see much use in explaining how to enable a use flag inside
ebuilds, at most there should be a pointer to the real documentation
IMO.
Marius
--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list
[gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
Hello,
I'd like to add the following function to eutils.eclass :
# Generate a standard error message for missing USE flags
# in existing packages, and die.
#
# Usage: built_with_use_die category/package functionality [USE flag]
#ex: built_with_use_die dev-util/subversion python
#or: built_with_use_die net-www/apache LDAP ldap
#
# Typical usage:
# if ! built_with_use dev-util/subversion python ; then
#built_with_use_die dev-util/subversion python
# fi
#
# Note: when USE flag is not specified, functionality is used for the USE
flag name.
built_with_use_die() {
local package=$1
local func=$2
local use_flag=$3
[[ -z ${use_flag} ]] use_flag=${func}
eerror Your ${package} package has been built without
eerror ${func} support, please enable the '${use_flag}' USE flag and
eerror re-emerge ${package}.
elog You can enable this USE flag either globally in /etc/make.conf,
elog or just for specific packages in /etc/portage/package.use.
die ${package} missing ${func} support
}
This function is already used in latest www-apps/trac ebuilds. The following
packages might be concerned, i.e. packages that are currently using
built_with_use() :
app-admin/system-config-httpd
app-admin/kedpm
app-admin/sabayon
app-admin/analog
app-admin/diradm
app-admin/moodss
app-admin/puppet
app-admin/keepassx
app-admin/webalizer
app-backup/bobs
app-cdr/k3b
app-cdr/dvdshrink
app-crypt/xca
app-crypt/gnupg
app-doc/kchmviewer
app-editors/joe
app-editors/gobby
app-emacs/emacs-w3m
app-emulation/wine
app-emulation/crossover-office-bin
app-emulation/crossover-office-pro-bin
app-emulation/xen-tools
app-i18n/uim
app-i18n/scim-bridge
app-i18n/scim-qtimm
app-misc/g15composer
app-misc/beagle
app-misc/gramps
app-misc/tracker
app-misc/tomboy
app-misc/webcomics-collector
app-office/krita
app-office/koffice
app-office/kmymoney2
app-office/tinyerp-server
app-office/gnucash
app-office/mozilla-sunbird
app-office/gnumeric
app-office/qbankmanager
app-pda/libsyncml
app-pda/libopensync-plugin-syncml
app-pda/libopensync-plugin-irmc
app-portage/elogv
app-portage/esearch
app-portage/porthole
app-portage/layman
app-text/an
app-text/xdvik
app-text/bibletime
app-text/biblestudy
app-text/evince
app-text/enscript
app-text/epdfview
app-text/gnome-doc-utils
dev-cpp/Ice
dev-cpp/libthrowable
dev-db/pgadmin3
dev-dotnet/galago-sharp
dev-games/ogre
dev-haskell/wxhaskell
dev-java/cairo-java
dev-java/velocity
dev-lang/lazarus
dev-lang/mercury-extras
dev-libs/g-wrap
dev-libs/m17n-lib
dev-lisp/sbcl
dev-ml/findlib
dev-ml/lablgl
dev-ml/ocamlnet
dev-php4/php-java-bridge
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-odbc
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-oci
dev-php5/php-qt
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-sqlite
dev-php5/pecl-pdo
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-dblib
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-mysql
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-pgsql
dev-python/pymssql
dev-python/pyzor
dev-python/soappy
dev-python/pyopengl
dev-python/imaging
dev-python/wxpython
dev-python/xapwrap
dev-python/telepathy-python
dev-ruby/ruby-gd
dev-ruby/sqlite3-ruby
dev-tcltk/thread
dev-tinyos/tos-getenv
dev-tinyos/tos-scripts
dev-util/meld
dev-util/pida
dev-util/source-highlight
dev-util/documancer
dev-util/dialog
dev-util/rapidsvn
dev-util/imediff2
dev-util/svnmailer
games-action/rrootage
games-action/powermanga
games-action/noiz2sa
games-arcade/frozen-bubble
games-arcade/supertux
games-arcade/pycadia
games-arcade/solarwolf
games-arcade/defendguin
games-arcade/project-starfighter
games-arcade/stepmania
games-arcade/smclone
games-arcade/tomatoes
games-arcade/monster-masher
games-arcade/ceferino
games-emulation/dosbox-cvs
games-emulation/dosbox
games-fps/qudos
games-fps/quake3-bin
games-fps/duke3d
games-fps/quake1-data
games-fps/quake2-data
games-fps/quake2-icculus
games-fps/doom3-dungeon
games-kids/cubetest
games-mud/lyntin
games-puzzle/xye
games-puzzle/twindistress
games-puzzle/flobopuyo
games-puzzle/monsterz
games-rpg/nwn
games-rpg/tmw
games-rpg/xu4
games-rpg/nwn-cep
games-simulation/gl117
games-simulation/openttd
games-simulation/lincity-ng
games-simulation/planets
games-sports/ultimatestunts
games-strategy/freelords
games-strategy/wesnoth
gnome-extra/evolution-data-server
gnome-extra/hal-device-manager
gnome-extra/gnome-games
gnome-extra/evolution-exchange
kde-base/kpdf
kde-base/kdebase
kde-base/kdelibs
kde-base/kdegraphics
kde-base/kopete
kde-base/kghostview
kde-base/kdemultimedia-arts
kde-base/kdenetwork
kde-base/kdebase-kioslaves
kde-misc/tork
kde-misc/kompose
kde-misc/kdnssd-avahi
mail-client/mozilla-thunderbird
mail-client/evolution
media-fonts/acroread-asianfonts
media-gfx/splashutils
media-gfx/gimp
media-gfx/pstoedit
media-gfx/gimp-print
media-gfx/hugin
media-gfx/graphviz
media-gfx/asymptote
media-gfx/f-spot
media-gfx/kphotoalbum
media-libs/mesa
media-libs/libipoddevice
media-libs/giblib
media-libs/libquicktime
media-libs/openinventor
media-libs/openexr
media-libs/ploticus
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice
media-plugins/kipi-plugins
media-plugins/quodlibet-trayicon
media-plugins/vdr-weatherng
Re: [gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
dju` kirjoitti: Hello, I'd like to add the following function to eutils.eclass : # Generate a standard error message for missing USE flags # in existing packages, and die. # # Usage: built_with_use_die category/package functionality [USE flag] #ex: built_with_use_die dev-util/subversion python #or: built_with_use_die net-www/apache LDAP ldap # # Typical usage: # if ! built_with_use dev-util/subversion python ; then #built_with_use_die dev-util/subversion python # fi # I think we should just call built_with_use inside built_with_use_die so it becomes just built_with_use_die dev-util/subversion python. Regards, Petteri signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: [gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
dju` wrote:
Hello,
I'd like to add the following function to eutils.eclass :
# Generate a standard error message for missing USE flags
# in existing packages, and die.
#
# Usage: built_with_use_die category/package functionality [USE flag]
#ex: built_with_use_die dev-util/subversion python
#or: built_with_use_die net-www/apache LDAP ldap
#
# Typical usage:
# if ! built_with_use dev-util/subversion python ; then
#built_with_use_die dev-util/subversion python
# fi
#
# Note: when USE flag is not specified, functionality is used for the USE
flag name.
Please look at the current built_with_use implementation and just wrap
that since it does some more checks. You're also missing support for the
--missing option.
built_with_use_die() {
local package=$1
local func=$2
local use_flag=$3
[[ -z ${use_flag} ]] use_flag=${func}
eerror Your ${package} package has been built without
eerror ${func} support, please enable the '${use_flag}' USE flag and
eerror re-emerge ${package}.
elog You can enable this USE flag either globally in /etc/make.conf,
elog or just for specific packages in /etc/portage/package.use.
die ${package} missing ${func} support
}
This function is already used in latest www-apps/trac ebuilds. The following
packages might be concerned, i.e. packages that are currently using
built_with_use() :
app-admin/system-config-httpd
app-admin/kedpm
app-admin/sabayon
app-admin/analog
app-admin/diradm
app-admin/moodss
app-admin/puppet
app-admin/keepassx
app-admin/webalizer
app-backup/bobs
app-cdr/k3b
app-cdr/dvdshrink
app-crypt/xca
app-crypt/gnupg
app-doc/kchmviewer
app-editors/joe
app-editors/gobby
app-emacs/emacs-w3m
app-emulation/wine
app-emulation/crossover-office-bin
app-emulation/crossover-office-pro-bin
app-emulation/xen-tools
app-i18n/uim
app-i18n/scim-bridge
app-i18n/scim-qtimm
app-misc/g15composer
app-misc/beagle
app-misc/gramps
app-misc/tracker
app-misc/tomboy
app-misc/webcomics-collector
app-office/krita
app-office/koffice
app-office/kmymoney2
app-office/tinyerp-server
app-office/gnucash
app-office/mozilla-sunbird
app-office/gnumeric
app-office/qbankmanager
app-pda/libsyncml
app-pda/libopensync-plugin-syncml
app-pda/libopensync-plugin-irmc
app-portage/elogv
app-portage/esearch
app-portage/porthole
app-portage/layman
app-text/an
app-text/xdvik
app-text/bibletime
app-text/biblestudy
app-text/evince
app-text/enscript
app-text/epdfview
app-text/gnome-doc-utils
dev-cpp/Ice
dev-cpp/libthrowable
dev-db/pgadmin3
dev-dotnet/galago-sharp
dev-games/ogre
dev-haskell/wxhaskell
dev-java/cairo-java
dev-java/velocity
dev-lang/lazarus
dev-lang/mercury-extras
dev-libs/g-wrap
dev-libs/m17n-lib
dev-lisp/sbcl
dev-ml/findlib
dev-ml/lablgl
dev-ml/ocamlnet
dev-php4/php-java-bridge
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-odbc
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-oci
dev-php5/php-qt
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-sqlite
dev-php5/pecl-pdo
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-dblib
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-mysql
dev-php5/pecl-pdo-pgsql
dev-python/pymssql
dev-python/pyzor
dev-python/soappy
dev-python/pyopengl
dev-python/imaging
dev-python/wxpython
dev-python/xapwrap
dev-python/telepathy-python
dev-ruby/ruby-gd
dev-ruby/sqlite3-ruby
dev-tcltk/thread
dev-tinyos/tos-getenv
dev-tinyos/tos-scripts
dev-util/meld
dev-util/pida
dev-util/source-highlight
dev-util/documancer
dev-util/dialog
dev-util/rapidsvn
dev-util/imediff2
dev-util/svnmailer
games-action/rrootage
games-action/powermanga
games-action/noiz2sa
games-arcade/frozen-bubble
games-arcade/supertux
games-arcade/pycadia
games-arcade/solarwolf
games-arcade/defendguin
games-arcade/project-starfighter
games-arcade/stepmania
games-arcade/smclone
games-arcade/tomatoes
games-arcade/monster-masher
games-arcade/ceferino
games-emulation/dosbox-cvs
games-emulation/dosbox
games-fps/qudos
games-fps/quake3-bin
games-fps/duke3d
games-fps/quake1-data
games-fps/quake2-data
games-fps/quake2-icculus
games-fps/doom3-dungeon
games-kids/cubetest
games-mud/lyntin
games-puzzle/xye
games-puzzle/twindistress
games-puzzle/flobopuyo
games-puzzle/monsterz
games-rpg/nwn
games-rpg/tmw
games-rpg/xu4
games-rpg/nwn-cep
games-simulation/gl117
games-simulation/openttd
games-simulation/lincity-ng
games-simulation/planets
games-sports/ultimatestunts
games-strategy/freelords
games-strategy/wesnoth
gnome-extra/evolution-data-server
gnome-extra/hal-device-manager
gnome-extra/gnome-games
gnome-extra/evolution-exchange
kde-base/kpdf
kde-base/kdebase
kde-base/kdelibs
kde-base/kdegraphics
kde-base/kopete
kde-base/kghostview
kde-base/kdemultimedia-arts
kde-base/kdenetwork
kde-base/kdebase-kioslaves
kde-misc/tork
kde-misc/kompose
kde-misc/kdnssd-avahi
mail-client/mozilla-thunderbird
mail-client/evolution
media-fonts/acroread-asianfonts
media-gfx/splashutils
media-gfx/gimp
media-gfx/pstoedit
Re: [gentoo-dev] add built_with_use_die() to eutils.eclass ?
* dju` [EMAIL PROTECTED] [07/04/23 23:45 +0200]: # Generate a standard error message for missing USE flags # in existing packages, and die. I dislike that an emerge process dies when a use-flag is not set (okay, it will die otherwise later with the package that needs the dependency with that special use-flag built). It should be better to break with an appropriate message _before_ anything will be compiled. Let's say, directly after portage has calculated the dependencies. Your proposal looks like a quick fix for a feature portage can't handle yet. But your attached list of packages which already use that behaviour is already quite long and so you better should convince the portage-devs to include built-use-flags into the dependency calculation. Regards, Lars PS: I should add the disclaimer, that I did not ask any of the portage devs before I wrote these lines. I only checked http://www.gentoo.org/proj/en/portage/index.xml#doc_chap8 and could not find that this feature is already in development. PPS: I know that there are other package-managers out there. And no, I don't want to use these. portage still fits my needs best. -- Lars Weiler [EMAIL PROTECTED] +49-171-1963258 Instant Messaging : [EMAIL PROTECTED] Gentoo Linux PowerPC : Strategical Lead and Release Engineer Gentoo Infrastructure : CVS Administrator pgpC8hoQtvhTK.pgp Description: PGP signature
