[geo] Re: Ocean fertilization - a scientific summary for Policy Makers

2014-06-22 Thread M V Bhaskar
Andrew Thank you. Quite a comprehensive report. Unfortunately quite a few important points are missing in the Scientific summary. The objective of Ocean Fertilization is to grow Diatom Algae, not just any Phytoplankton, because Diatoms sink and other plankton float on death. The report is

[geo] Adding Iron to the oceans

2014-06-22 Thread Keith Henson
It's a shame this business got mixed up with geoengineering because it is something that should be done on it's own merits. Humans fish the seas. As a result they remove vast amounts of elements from the materials circulating in the ocean biosphere. We are going to fish, and remove elements,

Re: [geo] Adding Iron to the oceans

2014-06-22 Thread Andrew Lockley
Approx 100MT annual catch Approx 1 part in 10 is iron Therefore need to replace 1000t iron pa into ocean ecosystems. But iron isn't a limiting nutrient everywhere, so perhaps far less. Should boats be tipping NPK fertiliser over the side, too? Far larger volumes are required. Marine reserves

Re: [geo] Adding Iron to the oceans

2014-06-22 Thread M V Bhaskar
Andrew You calculation is way of the mark. Iron does not cause growth of Fish directly, it only causes growth of phytoplankton. These are consumed by zooplankton and small fish and these by bigger fish. The Phytoplankton to Fish ratio for the large fish that people prefer to eat is about