Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-23 Thread Michael Hayes
Jim, I share your concerns over the question of "*does a con artist describe themselves as a con artist??):".* If they did, it would be something of a limiting factor in attracting donations to cover their salaries. Would you agree? BTW, how is your "peasant farming cools the planet" geoengineer

Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-15 Thread Ronal W. Larson
all of the rationale for CO2 management in that ocean acidification is not >>> addressed by the preceding "umbrella". In any case in describing my work my >>> tack has been to avoid the use of "geoengineering" and to explicitly state >>> what it is I&#x

Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-15 Thread Holly Buck
to address climate change. Still, the >>>> evolution of the umbrella term “geoengineering” into something more >>>> coherent and analytically stable is probably due." >>>> >>>> Agree that geoengineering is no longer descriptive or useful. As we've

Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-15 Thread Holly Buck
uot;CO2 >> mitigation", etc and let the evaluation of socio-ecological risks and >> benefits be based on the specific actions I'm proposing, and not biased by >> the real or imagined risk/benefit of some totally different approach like >> SRM. >> >> Greg >

Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-14 Thread Ronal W. Larson
> > From: Ronal W. Larson > To: Geoengineering > Cc: geoengineeringourclim...@gmail.com; Holly Buck > > Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2014 8:14 AM > Subject: Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration > > List with ccs > >1. Thank

Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-14 Thread Greg Rau
To: Geoengineering >Cc: geoengineeringourclim...@gmail.com; Holly Buck >Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2014 8:14 AM >Subject: Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration > > > >List with ccs > > >   1.   Thanks to Sean for the alert of a paper I thi

Re: [geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-14 Thread Ronal W. Larson
List with ccs 1. Thanks to Sean for the alert of a paper I think is important. Important on two grounds - the Haida/OIF controversy (I am not qualified to discuss, but think we have not heard enough) and the use of the term “Geoengineering” (where I have been regularly commenting and als

[geo] Case Study by Holly Buck on Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration

2014-01-14 Thread Geoengineering Our Climate (eds. Blackstock, Miller and Rayner)
Dear colleagues, For the *Geoengineering Our Climate?* Working Paper Series, Holly Buck (Cornell University) has written a case study on the Haida Gwaii OIF demonstration, titled: *"Village Science Meets Global Discourse: The Haida Salmon Restoration Corporation's Ocean Iron Fertilization Experime