Re: [geo] Re: Ethics of Geoengineering (anything new?)

2012-04-09 Thread Robert Tulip
The ethics of geoengineering is possibly the biggest philosophical problem facing the world, sitting at the intersection between philosophy and a range of practical disciplines.  Crucial moral decisions on geoengineering will affect the immediate fate of our planet.   Geoengineering certainly

[geo] Re: Ethics of Geoengineering (anything new?)

2012-04-08 Thread O Morton
I agree with Ninad; philosophy feeds on novelty in its continual reassessments; it doesn't assimilate it in a serial model of progress. Many philosophical problems are not solved (though they may be moved outside the realm of philosophy by other developments), and few are novel. There's a relevant

Re: [geo] Re: Ethics of Geoengineering (anything new?)

2012-04-08 Thread Ron Larson
Geoengineering list, especially Andrea Gammon I mainly write to ask if the University of Montana and other Universities doing ethics studies are considering Geoengineering to be identical to SRM - or whether the term also includes CDR. Of the dozen or so messages so far in this thread, I can

Re: [geo] Re: Ethics of Geoengineering (anything new?)

2012-04-08 Thread Ken Caldeira
I think I simply use the word 'philosophy' different than most modern philosophers. Just as I think of mathematicians developing new mathematical theory while the rest of us apply existing theory to do calculations aimed at solving real world pproblems, I thought philosophers were developing

[geo] Re: Ethics of Geoengineering (anything new?)

2012-04-07 Thread Nathan Currier
Sorry, I meant to post the below to this thread, in response to Ken's query, but hit the wrong button. On the other hand, the post of Andrea and Christopher makes me wonder how it will get interpreted the very approach to ethics here suggests a conventional framework in which what I raise

[geo] Re: Ethics of Geoengineering (anything new?)

2012-04-07 Thread Ninad Bondre
Ken, I am not sure why the question of anything new arose, but I agree with what Nathan states in the first paragraph of his earlier email. Some additional thoughts here as my view of philosophy differs from yours. Novelty doesn't play the same role in philosophical inquiry as it might in

Re: [geo] Re: Ethics of Geoengineering (anything new?)

2012-04-07 Thread Michael Hayes
Hi Folks, I have often found my thoughts on the ethics issue streaming back to the issue of the definition of GE. In short, the difference between '*intentional' *modification of the climate and *'unintentionaly',* yet knowingly, causing such at the second order (global) effect level seems to be