Re: [Gimp-developer] Some feedback on Gimp 1.3.x

2003-03-19 Thread Sven Neumann
Hi,

MArk Finlay [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 1. Everyone loves a good splash screen, but now Gnome has
 startup-notification which kinda makes them superflous. Startup
 notification lets you know that your applications is starting but it
 is not as intrusive as a splash. I have edited my Gimp Launcher to
 add the line 'StartupNotify=true' and to change it to run 'gimp-1.3
 -s'. To me this feels much snappier than before. And eventually when
 nautilus has integrated support for startup notification it would
 make sense to do the same for the gnome mime-type.

huh? I doubt that most of our users use Nautilus or even GNOME. The
current CVS version of The GIMP now properly supports startup
notification and there's a command-line option to disable the splash.
What more could you possibly ask for?

 I still use the right click, and never even notice the menu bar, but
 for every non-gimp user who sits down at my computer this
 effectively un-breaks the gimp for them. So what I am suggesting
 is that this toolbar be enabled by default.

If the menubar wouldn't be cut off at the right side but wrap, we
could even consider to do this. Since it is rather broken at it is
now, I don't want to see it as the default. Of course packagers are
free to change the default if they are bundling GIMP for newbies
That's as easy as changing one line in the system-wide gimprc.

 4. It be great in the Font selection dialog to be able to change the
 text from my mind is going... to see other characters in the font.
 Also it'd be better by default to replace this text with a selection
 of characters, numbers, upper and lower case letters and sysbols.

you should at least look at the latest version before you start to
criticize things that are known to be under construction.


Salut, Sven
___
Gimp-developer mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.xcf.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer


Re: [Gimp-developer] Some feedback on Gimp 1.3.x

2003-03-19 Thread Patrick McFarland
On 19-Mar-2003, Sven Neumann wrote:
 Hi,
 
 MArk Finlay [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
 
  1. Everyone loves a good splash screen, but now Gnome has
  startup-notification which kinda makes them superflous. Startup
  notification lets you know that your applications is starting but it
  is not as intrusive as a splash. I have edited my Gimp Launcher to
  add the line 'StartupNotify=true' and to change it to run 'gimp-1.3
  -s'. To me this feels much snappier than before. And eventually when
  nautilus has integrated support for startup notification it would
  make sense to do the same for the gnome mime-type.
 
 huh? I doubt that most of our users use Nautilus or even GNOME. The
 current CVS version of The GIMP now properly supports startup
 notification and there's a command-line option to disable the splash.
 What more could you possibly ask for?

I use openbox by itself, with no desktop environment at all. I guess I
represent the majority?

-- 
Patrick Diablo-D3 McFarland || [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Computer games don't affect kids; I mean if Pac-Man affected us as kids, we'd 
all be running around in darkened rooms, munching magic pills and listening to
repetitive electronic music. -- Kristian Wilson, Nintendo, Inc, 1989
___
Gimp-developer mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.xcf.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer


Re: [Gimp-developer] Some feedback on Gimp 1.3.x

2003-03-19 Thread Sven Neumann
Hi,

MArk Finlay [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 One idea is to put a toggle for it in the view menu and have it on by
 default. This way it will only take an expert user a second to turn it
 off(obviously it would stay off in future sessions too).

there is (of course) a toggle for it in the menu. But this menu only
affects this particular view (again of course).

 I think that Gnome2 has proven to an extent that what works for newbies
 in not necessarily restrictive for expert users, but I made that point
 in my origional e-mail so I'm not going to start waffling about it again

umm, this is the first time I hear this opinion. What I heard so far
is that Gnome2 lack so much of the beloved configurability that a lot
of expert users prefer to stay with the 1.4 version for now.


Salut, Sven
___
Gimp-developer mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.xcf.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer


Re: [Gimp-developer] Some feedback on Gimp 1.3.x

2003-03-19 Thread MArk Finlay

 huh? I doubt that most of our users use Nautilus or even GNOME. The
 current CVS version of The GIMP now properly supports startup
 notification and there's a command-line option to disable the splash.
 What more could you possibly ask for?

I guess I'm a bit of reasonable defaults whore. Options are great and
all but I think that software should Just Work(TM) by default. I'm not
saying that the right way is definately to turn off the splash. But I
guess I just like to question things that are assumed to be right
because that is the way they are ATM :)

Also, I wasn't suggesting that the splash be disabled by default for all
platforms - cus that would be stupid. I was just suggestion that the
gnome launcher be modified to disable the splash by default. 

 If the menubar wouldn't be cut off at the right side but wrap, we
 could even consider to do this. Since it is rather broken at it is
 now, I don't want to see it as the default. 

Well it being broken ATM isn't really a valid argument in terms of
whether it should be on or off in a long term way. I agree that turning
it on when it is broken would be a bad idea, but if the idea is going to
get shot down, it'd be better to shoot it down for better reasons, and
assuming that it will be fixed some day(soon hopefully).

One idea is to put a toggle for it in the view menu and have it on by
default. This way it will only take an expert user a second to turn it
off(obviously it would stay off in future sessions too).

 Of course packagers are
 free to change the default if they are bundling GIMP for newbies
 That's as easy as changing one line in the system-wide gimprc.

I think that Gnome2 has proven to an extent that what works for newbies
in not necessarily restrictive for expert users, but I made that point
in my origional e-mail so I'm not going to start waffling about it again
:)

 you should at least look at the latest version before you start to
 criticize things that are known to be under construction.

good point , will update to cvs.

-- 
 .--= [ MArk Finlay - sisob ] =--.

[ Gnome User's Board : www.gnomesupport.org/forums ]
[ Public Key: http://evolvedoo.sf.net/sisobatericomdotnet.asc  ]


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part