Re: "git checkout" safety feature
On Mon, Nov 5, 2018 at 7:53 AM Jeff King wrote: > > On Mon, Nov 05, 2018 at 07:24:42AM +0100, Matthias Urlichs wrote: > > > Hi, > > > "git checkout " is a feature to overwrite local > > > changes. It is what you use when you make a mess editing the files > > > and want to go back to a known state. Why should that feature be > > > destroyed? > > > > Not destroyed, but optionally made finger-fumble-save – like "alias rm > > rm -i". > > There are a couple of destructive commands left in Git (e.g., this one, > and "git reset --hard" is another). I didn't dig up archive references, > but the topic of safety valves has come up many times over the years. > The discussion usually ends with the notion that instead of warning > that the operation is destructive (because that gets annoying when its > purpose is to be destructive), we should make it possible to undo a > mistake. > > So in this case, that would mean saving the working tree file to a blob > before we obliterate it. > > See similar discussion in: > > > https://public-inbox.org/git/cacsjy8c5qolvg4pzy_pthqoygh9ohdevhxsuywqhqypn3ob...@mail.gmail.com/ > > for example. That work is still ongoing (slowly). I realized that reflog code was buried deep in files-backend.c and would not make sense to reuse in its current form. So I had to move the code to a common place, which adds more work. But it will be coming! Hopefully before 2020 at my usual development speed. While we're at it, I've been running something with that "index reflog" (no pruning) for a month with lots of "add -p" and the file size is just 163KB, so the reflog format seems promising for this purpose. -- Duy
Re: "git checkout" safety feature
On Mon, Nov 05, 2018 at 07:24:42AM +0100, Matthias Urlichs wrote: > Hi, > > "git checkout " is a feature to overwrite local > > changes. It is what you use when you make a mess editing the files > > and want to go back to a known state. Why should that feature be > > destroyed? > > Not destroyed, but optionally made finger-fumble-save – like "alias rm > rm -i". There are a couple of destructive commands left in Git (e.g., this one, and "git reset --hard" is another). I didn't dig up archive references, but the topic of safety valves has come up many times over the years. The discussion usually ends with the notion that instead of warning that the operation is destructive (because that gets annoying when its purpose is to be destructive), we should make it possible to undo a mistake. So in this case, that would mean saving the working tree file to a blob before we obliterate it. See similar discussion in: https://public-inbox.org/git/cacsjy8c5qolvg4pzy_pthqoygh9ohdevhxsuywqhqypn3ob...@mail.gmail.com/ for example. -Peff
Re: "git checkout" safety feature
Hi, > "git checkout " is a feature to overwrite local > changes. It is what you use when you make a mess editing the files > and want to go back to a known state. Why should that feature be > destroyed? Not destroyed, but optionally made finger-fumble-save – like "alias rm rm -i". -- -- Matthias Urlichs signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: "git checkout" safety feature
Matthias Urlichs writes: > A recent discussion on LWN https://lwn.net/Articles/770642/ noted that > "git checkout " does not warn if one if the files has > been modified locally, nor is there an option to do so. > > IMHO that should be fixed, preferably by somebody who knows git's > internals well enough to do so in half an hour ;-) "git checkout " is a feature to overwrite local changes. It is what you use when you make a mess editing the files and want to go back to a known state. Why should that feature be destroyed?
"git checkout" safety feature
Hi, A recent discussion on LWN https://lwn.net/Articles/770642/ noted that "git checkout " does not warn if one if the files has been modified locally, nor is there an option to do so. IMHO that should be fixed, preferably by somebody who knows git's internals well enough to do so in half an hour ;-) -- -- Matthias Urlichs signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
