Re: Is there a way to have local changes in a branch 'bake' while working in different branches?

[John Keeping]

On Thu, Dec 15, 2016 at 08:14:58PM +, Larry Minton wrote:
> My question:
> 
> Let's say I have a code change that I want to 'bake' for a while
> locally, just to make sure some edge case doesn't pop up while I am
> working on other things.  Is there any practical way of doing that?  I
> could constantly merge that 'bake me' branch into other branches as I
> work on them and then remove those changes from the branches before
> sending them out for code review, but sooner or later pretty much
> guaranteed to screw that up

I wrote a tool [1] a while ago to manage integration branches so I use a
personal integration branch to pull together various in-progress
branches.

It means you can keep each topic in its own branch but work/test on top
of a unified branch by running:

git integration --rebuild my-integration-branch

whenever you change one of the topic branches.

I also use the instruction sheet to keep track of abandoned topics that
I might want to go back to but which are currently in a broken state,
you can see an example of that in my CGit integration branch [2].


[1] http://johnkeeping.github.io/git-integration/
[2] 
https://github.com/johnkeeping/cgit/blob/d01ce31ed3dfa9b05ef971464da2af5b9d6f2756/GIT-INTEGRATION-INSN

Re: Is there a way to have local changes in a branch 'bake' while working in different branches?

[Junio C Hamano]

Larry Minton  writes:

> Lars Schneider recommended I ask you this question.
>
> My question:
>
> Let's say I have a code change that I want to 'bake' for a while
> locally, just to make sure some edge case doesn't pop up while I
> am working on other things. Is there any practical way of doing
> that?

That sounds exactly like what I have been doing for the past several
years in public around here ;-)

Re: Is there a way to have local changes in a branch 'bake' while working in different branches?

[Aaron Schrab]

At 20:14 + 15 Dec 2016, Larry Minton  wrote:
Let's say I have a code change that I want to 'bake' for a while 
locally, just to make sure some edge case doesn't pop up while I am 
working on other things.  Is there any practical way of doing that?
I could constantly merge that 'bake me' branch into other branches as I 
work on them and then remove those changes from the branches before 
sending them out for code review, but sooner or later pretty much 
guaranteed to screw that up


That sounds like the best way to me. How do you envision screwing it up?

If you anticipate messing up while removing the changes, that's only 
likely if there are conflicts and any other strategy is likely to be 
worse there.


If you suspect you'll forget to remove them before sending for code 
review there may be ways to help with that. Easiest you can add a large 
notice in the commit message(s) and/or comments; this may not prevent 
going for review but reviewers should catch it pretty quickly. To help 
prevent it even getting that far you may be able to add a pre-push hook 
to prevent such commits from being pushed to somewhere other than a 
private fork or a branch with a name that clearly indicates that it 
contains experimental code.

Is there a way to have local changes in a branch 'bake' while working in different branches?

[Larry Minton]

Lars Schneider recommended I ask you this question.

My question:

Let's say I have a code change that I want to 'bake' for a while locally, just 
to make sure some edge case doesn't pop up while I am working on other things.  
Is there any practical way of doing that? 
I could constantly merge that 'bake me' branch into other branches as I work on 
them and then remove those changes from the branches before sending them out 
for code review, but sooner or later pretty much guaranteed to screw that up

His response:

Good question. Your merging idea would work but I agree it might be cumbersome. 
In this situation I keep modified files in my tree. That would work for you 
too, but this would be inconvenient if you have many changed files. I wonder 
how the Git core guys manage this kind of situation.

Thanks,

Larry Minton
3ds Max Core team
LiveDesign Group
Media & Entertainment, Education Experiences, Impact (MEI)