Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-03-01 Thread Derek Martin
On Mon, Mar 01, 2004 at 11:26:04AM -0500, Michael ODonnell wrote: > Followup article on ESR's rant, including input from > the CUPS folks and other feedback... > > http://www.newsforge.com/software/04/03/01/1453218.shtml Best and most important part of this one: Remember the Macintosh dictum

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-03-01 Thread Michael ODonnell
Followup article on ESR's rant, including input from the CUPS folks and other feedback... http://www.newsforge.com/software/04/03/01/1453218.shtml ___ gnhlug-discuss mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://mail.gnhlug.org/mailman/listinfo/gnhlug-discu

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-29 Thread Jason Stephenson
I agree with John Abreau completely on this one. I remember reading a joke online about what if people drove their cars the way they operate computers. I am not going to place the blame solely on Microsoft for this, but it is my feeling, from working with "non-tech savvy" people all the time,

BSOD (was: Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary)

2004-02-28 Thread bmcculley
Derek Martin wrote: > >On Sat, Feb 28, 2004 at 03:33:17AM -0500, Dana S. Tellier wrote: >> And I have to be honest with you, I don't know where *you* see blue >> screens anymore, but in all of the environments I've done support lately, I >> haven't seen any blue screens; there are still plenty

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-28 Thread bmcculley
Derek Martin wrote: > >I will say this though: In today's world, the computer is >an essential tool which is used by virtually all job functions >for a variety of tasks. It has become a basic essential >skill. If we are not teaching computer skills to our children >along with reading, writin

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-28 Thread Derek Martin
On Sat, Feb 28, 2004 at 03:33:17AM -0500, Dana S. Tellier wrote: > And I have to be honest with you, I don't know where *you* see blue > screens anymore, but in all of the environments I've done support lately, I > haven't seen any blue screens; there are still plenty of other problems, but > t

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-28 Thread Dana S. Tellier
From: "John Abreau" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> The Redhat printer config tool that ESR was bitching about is truly a piece of crap. But the technolazy behaviors that Microsoft promotes are as reckless as telling drivers that the car will obey the traffic rules automatically. Teaching drivers that attitu

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-28 Thread Dana S. Tellier
From: "Derek Martin" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> I will say this though: In today's world, the computer is an essential tool which is used by virtually all job functions for a variety of tasks. It has become a basic essential skill. If we are not teaching computer skills to our children along with rea

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-28 Thread John Abreau
On Fri, 2004-02-27 at 16:54, Dana S. Tellier wrote: > I think ESR hits the nail on the head in this > idea of the "luxury of ignorance". I find it wonderful that I don't need to > know a damned thing about the inner workings of my car in order to drive it. > And when something goes wrong, I take

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Derek Martin
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 04:54:48PM -0500, Dana S. Tellier wrote: > But as for general users, I completely disagree that computer folk > should have a sort of high-minded "well, I took the time to learn, so should > you" attitude. For one thing, that's just plain arrogant. Secondly, these > pe

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread bmcculley
Mark Komarinski wrote: > >> > Probe the network for what other kinds of systems are out there? What >> > is he smoking? >> >> I assume from this comment that you don't like the idea of probing the >> LAN for equipment inventory info. This seems to have become a standard >> administrative techni

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Dana S. Tellier
From: "Derek Martin" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >Besides which, ESR's point was (if I may be allowed to interpret) >that if you design the interface properly, techies and non-techies >alike are a lot less likely to a) get it wrong and b) have to spend 18 >hours sifting through documentation to figure it

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Derek Martin
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 09:15:32AM -0500, brian wrote: > On Thu, 2004-02-26 at 21:34, Jeff Kinz wrote: > > ESR's point is that the folsk designing the GUI's need ot think at the > > problem from a perspective much closer the user's point of view. > > Yes, programmers should all cater to the fact t

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Mark Komarinski
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 01:12:15PM -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 10:32:04AM -0500, Mark Komarinski wrote: > > On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 09:47:23AM -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > > > He is correct about the difficulty his "Aunt Tilly" would have > > > trying to use the existing printer

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Kevin D. Clark
Jeff Kinz writes: > I have seen this type of thing be done in an intelligent and efficient > fashion. I prefer the multi-cast model myself - 1 broadcast, goes out > across the corporate network, and is received by everyone that needs to > know about it. (Now we're down to n*k xmits. :) ) VLANs

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Jeff Kinz
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 10:32:04AM -0500, Mark Komarinski wrote: > On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 09:47:23AM -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > > He is correct about the difficulty his "Aunt Tilly" would have > > trying to use the existing printer over the small network were correct > > (Using that interface). >

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Mark Komarinski
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 09:47:23AM -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 07:58:45AM -0500, Mark Komarinski wrote: > > On Thu, Feb 26, 2004 at 09:34:58PM -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > > > In an Ironic side twist, coincidental to one of the recently active threads > > > in gnhlug-discuss, ESR

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Mark Komarinski
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 10:53:34AM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > > However his "idea" that the whole thing > > should just discover your network and list for you only the available > > options is tad bit off as well. > > Why is making networks easier to use a bad idea? Because it's impractica

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread brian
On Fri, 2004-02-27 at 10:53, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > > However his "idea" that the whole thing > > should just discover your network and list for you only the available > > options is tad bit off as well. > > Why is making networks easier to use a bad idea? It is not, when done right. But it'

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Jeff Kinz
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 07:58:45AM -0500, Mark Komarinski wrote: > On Thu, Feb 26, 2004 at 09:34:58PM -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > > In an Ironic side twist, coincidental to one of the recently active threads > > in gnhlug-discuss, ESR is examining the issues he encountered whilst > > attempting to co

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread travis
> However his "idea" that the whole thing > should just discover your network and list for you only the available > options is tad bit off as well. Why is making networks easier to use a bad idea? > How would it know that you had > permissions to actually print to each printer? It should be able

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread brian
On Thu, 2004-02-26 at 21:34, Jeff Kinz wrote: > ESR's point is that the folsk designing the GUI's need ot think at the > problem from a perspective much closer the user's point of view. Yes, programmers should all cater to the fact that for some reason people think that they can be blissfully igno

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Mark Komarinski
On Fri, Feb 27, 2004 at 08:04:30AM -0500, Michael ODonnell wrote: > > > > In an Ironic side twist, coincidental to one of the recently > > active threads in gnhlug-discuss, ESR is examining the issues he > > encountered whilst attempting to configure a printer using the > > CUPS GUI config tool.

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Michael ODonnell
> In an Ironic side twist, coincidental to one of the recently > active threads in gnhlug-discuss, ESR is examining the issues he > encountered whilst attempting to configure a printer using the > CUPS GUI config tool. Wow, thanks for that one - now I don't feel so bad. Having gone through a sim

Re: Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-27 Thread Mark Komarinski
On Thu, Feb 26, 2004 at 09:34:58PM -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > In an Ironic side twist, coincidental to one of the recently active threads > in gnhlug-discuss, ESR is examining the issues he encountered whilst > attempting to configure a printer using the CUPS GUI config tool. AFAIK, CUPS has no GU

Examination of a Linux Gui, w/color commentary

2004-02-26 Thread Jeff Kinz
In an Ironic side twist, coincidental to one of the recently active threads in gnhlug-discuss, ESR is examining the issues he encountered whilst attempting to configure a printer using the CUPS GUI config tool. ESR's point is that the folsk designing the GUI's need ot think at the problem from a p