Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-05-28 Thread Bruce Labitt
fstab updated.  Just needed to use UUID=, not PARTUUID.  I do notice significantly long boot times now, guess it takes a while to get the RAID1 up.  Used to take 5 seconds to be available to ssh into, now takes about 45 seconds to a minute. I think I'd like the server to initiate the backup. 

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-05-27 Thread John Abreau
I've been running CentOS NAS servers for the past 15 years. I can usually find a decent rackmount server on eBay for around $99 that I imagine was probably used in the financial industry for a year or so and then turned over to a liquidator for disposal. I then load the drive bays with SATA drives

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-05-27 Thread Tom Buskey
In my mind, the client is what gets backed up. The host stores it. I hadn't considered ransomware. I think ZFS snapshots on the host would work well w/o using much more space. @Bruce Labitt I did Solaris up until just after the Oracle takeover (Solaris 11 even!), including some at home. I've

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-05-26 Thread Bruce Labitt
Thanks for the compliment. Put a bit of work into it. Self taught hobby machinist. Self taught Linux as well. Only have had machines for 18 months. Embarrassed to say how long I've been using Linux, as I keep on asking basic questions. On Wed, May 26, 2021, 12:14 PM Tom Buskey wrote: > My

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-05-26 Thread Ken D'Ambrosio
On 2021-05-26 12:13, Tom Buskey wrote: My Fedora /etc/fstab has spaces UUID=54103729-6e0a-4345-a2b8-8b8cded29ee1 /boot ext4 defaults1 2 I've had clients initiate rsync for security. I think the client initiation would offload the rsync compute from the server.

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-05-26 Thread Tom Buskey
My Fedora /etc/fstab has spaces UUID=54103729-6e0a-4345-a2b8-8b8cded29ee1 /boot ext4 defaults1 2 I've had clients initiate rsync for security. I think the client initiation would offload the rsync compute from the server. For a home server, it's nice to just monitor

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-05-26 Thread Bruce Labitt
Finally back to this.  Built a stack of metal plates that house my RPI4, a boot SSD, a 1TB RAID1 array, and both active and passive USB3 hubs.  Machined parts so everything is bolted and clamped down.  Have a PWM fan that cools the RPI4 proportional to load that runs under systemd.  System

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-10 Thread Bruce Labitt
I'll take a look at that. Thanks for the link. On Wed, Mar 10, 2021 at 8:15 PM Marc Nozell (m...@nozell.com) < noz...@gmail.com> wrote: > Just to put a plug in for a colleague's work: > https://perfectmediaserver.com/It covers everything from disk > purchasing strategies, burn-in,

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-10 Thread Bruce Labitt
Actually, at the moment I am forced to run on a RPI4-4GB. My laptop PS died. I'm aware of many of the downfalls of an RPI, I've had a few PI's over the ages. Mercifully, they are getting better. One cannot run an SSD AND and active USB3 hub both plugged directly into the 2 available USB3

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-10 Thread Marc Nozell (m...@nozell.com)
Just to put a plug in for a colleague's work: https://perfectmediaserver.com/It covers everything from disk purchasing strategies, burn-in, filesystems (ZFS, SnapRAID, etc). He also hosts a podcast that folks here may find interesting: https://selfhosted.show/ -marc On Wed, Mar 10, 2021 at

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-10 Thread jonhall80
OK: s/RPi4/some-other-cheap-computer-with-USB-3.x>/g Unless you build multiple Ethernet or WiFi or LTE modem connections your networking will still be the slowest thing. You do not need huge amounts of CPU power, or huge amounts of RAM. My basic point is that if you stick with simple RAID

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-10 Thread Joshua Judson Rosen
I'm not sure about the Raspberry Pi 4, but up thru the raspi 3+ there are... problems, e.g.: Beware of USB on the raspi: there are some bugs in the silicon that pretty severely cripple performance when multiple `bulk' devices are used at simultaneously, sometimes to the point of making it

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-10 Thread Tom Buskey
And make sure you get alerts when something fails. There are a number of commercial NAS like Synology out there if you don't want to build it yourself. I'd also add some kind of offsite storage. If you have decent internet speed, cloud storage is a good choice. Something with error correction

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-08 Thread jonhall80
I forgot one thing: Set up a shell script to do a simple diagnostic on both systems to detect a failed or failing system. Run two or three times a day. md > On 03/08/2021 9:56 PM jonhal...@comcast.net wrote: > > > I will suggest something and let people rip it apart: > >

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-08 Thread jonhall80
I will suggest something and let people rip it apart: Get two RPis that have at least USB 2.0 Attach two large capacity disks to each one in a RAID-1 configuration (also known as "mirroring") to keep it simple. If one disk fails the other will still keep working (but you should replace it as

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-08 Thread jsf
I know this is not really an answer to the question but I've spun up a small server on AWS with some storage that I snapshot every 6 hours.. i installed 'owncloud' on the server and i have an owncloud client on my laptop and my iphone.. really happy with it.. share the space with the whole family.

Re: Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-08 Thread bruce.lab...@myfairpoint.net
Nuts, what I meant was NAS.  There's open media vault, are there others that "easy enough" for relative beginners? ⁣Get BlueMail for Android ​ On Mar 8, 2021, 7:35 PM, at 7:35 PM, Bruce Labitt wrote: >For the second time in 3 months I have had a computer failure. Oddly, >it >was a PS on the

Have suggestions for a "roll your own file server"?

2021-03-08 Thread Bruce Labitt
For the second time in 3 months I have had a computer failure. Oddly, it was a PS on the motherboard both times. (Two different MB's.) Fortunately the disks were ok. I'm living on borrowed time. Next time, I may not be that lucky. Need a file server system with some sort of RAID redundancy.