Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread Amanjit Gill
Hi there, - I really like the GNU GPL and LGPL for software that corresponds to infrastructure (i.e. things that should be provided on any system, and must be free and interoperatable because it is so easy for software to be incompatible (you only need to change one byte). - I pretty much

Re: Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread David Kastrup
Amanjit Gill [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: - I really like the GNU GPL and LGPL for software that corresponds to infrastructure (i.e. things that should be provided on any system, and must be free and interoperatable because it is so easy for software to be incompatible (you only need to change

Re: Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread John Hasler
Amanjit Gill writes: I pretty much dislike the GPL (and LGPL because of the clause that you can relicense the work under the GPL) for everything else, i.e. Applications. So use the LGPL with an added restriction (which will make it incompatible with the GPL). I am looking for a BSD-style

Re: Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread Amanjit Gill
So use the LGPL with an added restriction (which will make it incompatible with the GPL). Yeah, so I could do LGPL+restriction / GPL dual licensing. Hmm not nice. First of all I will reconsider if GPL is really a no-no for me. incompatible. Ok. Use the BSD license and add a

Re: Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread David Kastrup
Amanjit Gill [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: David Kastrup schrieb: That is the wrong reason to like the GPL/LGPL, since both of them guarantee the freedom to change the code. Yes, but again nobody really changes platform / infrastructure code _behaviour_ or high level interface _contracts_ on a

Re: Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread John Hasler
Amanjit Gill writes: Yes, but as soon as it ends up as being GPL it can never go back to BSD. No. Code released under the BSD license remains under the BSD license. The derivative work created by combining BSD and GPL code may only be distributed under the GPL, but you can pull out the BSD

Re: Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread David Kastrup
John Hasler [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Amanjit Gill writes: Yes, but as soon as it ends up as being GPL it can never go back to BSD. No. Code released under the BSD license remains under the BSD license. The derivative work created by combining BSD and GPL code may only be distributed

Re: Looking for an open source license..

2006-06-05 Thread David Kastrup
John Hasler [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I wrote: The derivative work created by combining BSD and GPL code may only be distributed under the GPL, but you can pull out the BSD stuff (assuming you can't find the original BSD code elsewhere) and redistribute it under the BSD. David Kastrup