Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-29 Thread Hyman Rosen
> Matt Asay wrote: Free software has lost. Open source has won. This is the usual preposterous nonsense from those who willfully misunderstand and misrepresent the difference between the two. ___ gnu-misc-discuss mailing list gnu-misc-discuss@gnu.org

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Rick
On Sun, 27 Sep 2009 22:49:27 +, Azz Pizz wrote: > Rick wrote in > news:puydnzbdwypofilxnz2dnuvz_r5i4...@supernews.com: > >> On Sun, 27 Sep 2009 22:04:13 +, Azz Pizz wrote: >> >>> Rick wrote in >>> news:kkadnbabnz7z-clxnz2dnuvz_redn...@supernews.com: >>> >>> No, the intent is for

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Rick
On Sun, 27 Sep 2009 22:04:13 +, Azz Pizz wrote: > Rick wrote in > news:kkadnbabnz7z-clxnz2dnuvz_redn...@supernews.com: > > >> No, the intent is for the copyrights to remain in place. >> >> > Isn't for a lot of people the waiver an additional reason to not make it > public domain? What?

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Snit
Rjack stated in post mdednbh7m6qg8ylxnz2dnuvz_vcdn...@giganews.com on 9/27/09 6:52 AM: > Snit wrote: >> Rick stated in post kkadnbabnz7z-clxnz2dnuvz_redn...@supernews.com >> on 9/27/09 6:15 AM: >> The idiotic attempt by Richard Stallman to re-define the meaning of the word "free" is an

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Rjack
Snit wrote: Rick stated in post kkadnbabnz7z-clxnz2dnuvz_redn...@supernews.com on 9/27/09 6:15 AM: The idiotic attempt by Richard Stallman to re-define the meaning of the word "free" is an abject failure. Stallman has not tried to re-difine free. Get a dictionary. The dictionary does not tal

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Snit
Rick stated in post kkadnbabnz7z-clxnz2dnuvz_redn...@supernews.com on 9/27/09 6:15 AM: >> The idiotic attempt by Richard Stallman to re-define the meaning of the >> word "free" is an abject failure. > > Stallman has not tried to re-difine free. Get a dictionary. The dictionary does not talk abou

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Rjack
ever been granted by a United States Federal Court. All GPL complaints have been voluntarily withdrawn long before a judge could ever read a single word of the license. The point of Matt Assay's CNET article: Free software is dead. Long live open source http://news.cnet.com/openroad/ is tha

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Rjack
Rick wrote: On Sun, 27 Sep 2009 08:57:54 -0400, Rjack wrote: Rjack wrote: The GPL's failure is the fanatic desire of its authors to control other folk's contributions. The GPL doesn't try to control anything. It was written to make sure code couldn't be removed from community benefit. Hav

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Rick
nted by a United States Federal Court. All > GPL complaints have been voluntarily withdrawn long before a judge could > ever read a single word of the license. The cases have been settled, not withdrawn. And, AFAIK, the cases have resulted in the source code being distributed. > > The poi

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-27 Thread Rui Maciel
Rjack wrote: > Why do you want to take control of another author's BSD licensed code? > The BSD author has already freely offered it to anyone who chooses to > use it. Only anti-capitalist GPL control freaks want to control other > author's source code. The funny thing is that quite a few compani

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-26 Thread Rjack
Azz Pizz wrote: Rjack wrote in news:t9ydnbrayq6e3sdxnz2dnuvz_jcdn...@giganews.com: It appears that the Free Software Foundation is rapidly succeeding in killing off "Free Software". I was extremely unhappy when in the GPLv3 drafting process Stallman's idea of banning "trusted" computing

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-26 Thread Moshe Goldfarb
On Sat, 26 Sep 2009 17:29:03 +1200, Adam wrote: > So what is the new Michael Moore film like ? > Anyone seen it ? I've met Michael several times and despite my being a right winger, to a degree, I like him. He is a very intelligent person who really tries to make you think. Actually he is brilli

Re: Free software is dead.

2009-09-25 Thread Moshe Goldfarb
> and useless as it is in government. > > Free software has lost. Open source has won. We're all the better for it." > > September 25, 2009 10:42 AM PDT > Free software is dead. Long live open source > by Matt Asay > http://news.cnet.com/openroad/ > >

Free software is dead.

2009-09-25 Thread Rjack
;re all the better for it." September 25, 2009 10:42 AM PDT Free software is dead. Long live open source by Matt Asay http://news.cnet.com/openroad/ Sincerely, Rjack ___ gnu-misc-discuss mailing list gnu-misc-discuss@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnu-misc-discuss