Re: Mandates: Practical Questions

2010-09-02 Thread Sally Morris
When I looked at OA journals a few years ago I found that (a) they tended to publish very little and (b) they seemed much more likely to disappear or wither on the vine Sally When is a journal not a journal? A closer look at the DOAJ. Sally Morris, Learned Publishing Vol 19: 1, pp73-6, Jan

Re: Mandates: Practical Questions

2010-09-02 Thread Dana Roth
Could this be due to the failure of a business model that depends on donated time/money? Which sounds similar to the inherent problems with the SCOAP3 initiative from CERN. Dana L. Roth Millikan Library Caltech 1-32 1200 E. California Blvd. Pasadena, CA 91125 626-395-6423 fax:626-792-7540

Re: Mandates: Practical Questions

2010-09-02 Thread Heather Morrison
On 2-Sep-10, at 5:15 AM, Sally Morris wrote: When I looked at OA journals a few years ago I found that (a) they tended to publish very little and (b) they seemed much more likely to disappear or wither on the vine Sally When is a journal not a journal? A closer look at the DOAJ. Sally Morris,

Re: Mandates: Practical Questions

2010-09-02 Thread Dana Roth
Jan makes some good points but I think that a distinction should be made between society publishers and commercial publishers. I find it hard to imagine that the significance of society publishers is diminishing rapidly given the rapidly growing importance of their journals. Doesn't the future