RE: [AMERICAN-SCIENTIST-OPEN-ACCESS-FORUM] Repositories: Institutional or Central ? [in French, from Rector's blog, U. Li�ge]

2009-02-06 Thread Arthur Sale
Let me make a clear distinction between ~U Subject-based repositories, and ~U Multi-disciplinary repositories. The rhetoric about institutional repositories arises because (a) they are multi-disciplinary, and (b) because the owning institutions are empowered to mandate deposit. No

Re: [AMERICAN-SCIENTIST-OPEN-ACCESS-FORUM] Repositories: Institutional or Central ? [in French, from Rector's blog, U. Li�ge]

2009-02-06 Thread Leslie Carr
On 6 Feb 2009, at 00:02, Thomas Krichel wrote: Arthur Sale writes I totally disagree that researchers should be free to deposit where they will. This one of the basic tennants of academic fredom. Academic freedom relates to a professor's freedom to choose to profess (ie teach and

Re: [AMERICAN-SCIENTIST-OPEN-ACCESS-FORUM] Repositories: Institutional or Central ? [in French, from Rector's blog, U. Li�ge]

2009-02-05 Thread Thomas Krichel
Arthur Sale writes I totally disagree that researchers should be free to deposit where they will. This one of the basic tennants of academic fredom. Instititutional mandates reduce that freedom. That's why I, and many other academics, oppose mandates. Cheers, Thomas Krichel