Re: [Goanet]Catholic Goans and caste

2005-02-26 Thread Mario Goveia
cornel [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Basilio, Many thanks for the clarification you provided. I will immediately accept, from you, that you cannot be rightly placed with Gilbert Lawrence as defending the indefensible on caste. However, I must say that your preference for dealing with caste among the

[Goanet]Catholic Goans and caste

2005-02-24 Thread cornel
Basilio, Many thanks for the clarification you provided. I will immediately accept, from you, that you cannot be rightly placed with Gilbert Lawrence as defending the indefensible on caste. However, I must say that your preference for dealing with caste among the Catholic Goans is intriguing to

[Goanet]Catholic Goans and Caste

2005-02-24 Thread cornel
Cecil, In all my many posts on the topic of Catholic Goans and caste, you will find that, it is very unlikely I personally used the term Brahmins upon whom to focus. I always used, in my preferred terminogy, the term-- the casteists. This is because I am entirely aware that casteism is many

[Goanet]Catholic Goans and Caste

2005-02-22 Thread cornel
Hi Gilbert, I am sorry I could not get back to you sooner because of travel/business but I was very conscious that I had to read your response to me and reply asap. However, on now reading your points to me, I got a distinct feeling that you were presenting, with great respect, an incredibly