Dear Tim, Ron and Mario,
Point taken. A few responses preceded by ***.
Quoting Tim de Mello [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
(Copying this to Herman Fred as some of my posting to Goa-Net mysteriously
disappear.)
*** It's not fair to say that your posts mysteriously disappear as if we
discard them
We on Goanet Admin are tuned in to the diverse feedback on this subject,
and would like to hear viewpoints of others too.
The question here is: should there be the possibility of calling to an end
a discussion which goes on for a fairly lengthy period of time, and which
seems to be turning
Fred,
As you will have surmised, I agree with Tim entirely on the matter of the
unnecessary closure of an exciting theme. We may need to wait a long time to
come across something equally invigorating.
I also want to reiterate what I had said earlier, that, I disagree
profoundly with Mario re
From: Mario Goveia [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Fred,
We may just have to agree to disagree. However, your
specific comments cry out for some rebuttals:
Far be it for me to defend Mario on his political views but on this e-mail I
have to agree with him.
Most of the exchange of e-mails on
TO: Frederick Noronha(FN)
Fred,
We may just have to agree to disagree. However, your
specific comments cry out for some rebuttals:
Fred writes:
(i) Free speech doesn't mean saying what we want,
whenever we want, in disproportionate amounts, and
impose it on others who are then told to use the
Gabe,
Mea culpa a thousand times if I had unknowingly stolen your thunder on a
topic which may now not bear its name on Goanet! You know what I mean?
A happy new year.
Cornel
On Fri, 31 Dec 2004, Mario Goveia wrote:
However, with all due respect, I find it patently
offensive that some Goanetters irritation with
certain subjects and continuing debates should trample
on the free speech rights of others who may disagree.
If such ideas prevail we have anarchy, sometimes
[Goanet]Betting odds?
Mario Goveia goanet@goanet.org
I previously said in a post:
Who quit and made Herman the Dada? Who is Herman
anyway? Never heard of him before now.
I have since learned:
I now know who Herman is and that he started Goanet,
and so he is legitimately its Dada. Herman, I
I previously said in a post:
Who quit and made Herman the Dada? Who is Herman
anyway? Never heard of him before now.
I have since learned:
I now know who Herman is and that he started Goanet,
and so he is legitimately its Dada. Herman, I
salute you for your initiative in starting Goanet.
On Thu, 30 Dec 2004, Mario Goveia wrote:
Who quit and made Herman the Dada? Who is Herman
anyway? Never heard of him before now.
Old jungle saying: If you don't know the facts, it's best not to shoot
your mouth ;-) FN
TO: Tim de Mello [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Who quit and made Herman the Dada? Who is Herman
anyway? Never heard of him before now.
===
I agree with Cornel re: closing debate.
If I am not mistaken, Herman does not own GoaNet.
I thought we
Tim, I think you're posing the wrong question and therefore risk
suggesting a misleading answer. Also, two issues are getting mixed-up
here -- the structure of Goanet, and the advisability of closing
discussions.
On Thu, 30 Dec 2004, Tim de Mello wrote:
I agree with Cornel re: closing debate.
For the record, the stated identity of this poster is
bogus, which is made all the more obvious since this
phony poster is also severly spelling challenged with
respect to last names.
From: marlon menezes [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [Goanet] Betting odds?
X-Originating-Ip: 213.132.254.2
I agree with Cornel re: closing debate.
If I am not mistaken, Herman does not own GoaNet.
I thought we had agreed that debates should carry on until they die a
natural death. Appeals may be made for the participants to end debates but,
by no means, should it be dictated by anyone.
I take very
Cornel writes:
Goanetters,
I have only just seen, the 24 hour notice, that today is the last day when
material re Iraq, and the last American elections are permissible on Goanet.
Even if I am the only one to say this, I feel that this is an instance of a
tragic dictatorial mistake by a
From: cornel [EMAIL PROTECTED] Wrote To:
goanet@goanet.org
Sent: Thursday, December 30, 2004 10:47 AM
Subject: [Goanet]Betting odds?
Do I now take it that the Ribander case, albeit set in Goa, which has
been on Goanet much longer than the USA issue, is next for the chop?
After all a precedent
Goanetters,
I have only just seen, the 24 hour notice, that today is the last day
when material re Iraq, and the last American elections are permissible on
Goanet. Even if I am the only one to say this, I feel that this is an
instance of a tragic dictatorial mistake by a small
17 matches
Mail list logo
